Yuri Manga: Strawberry Panic, Volume 2

December 5th, 2006

Welcome to “schoolgirls” week on Okazu.

Feel my excitement as I contemplate yet another half dozen manga with pretty much the exact same subject. I hope you’ll forgive my lack of enthusiasm – I have a cold and a cranky attitude.

Let’s start with the “omg, most AWESOME 4tw, this series roxors!!!!11111” series since Kannazuki no Miko, shall we? I am of course, speaking of Strawberry Panic which, by the sheer number of emails and comments that look like the above phrase, has an even less discriminating sophisticated fanbase than KnM.

And yet.

I read it. I enjoy it. I find it amusing. (For those of you tempted to write in that I am a moron because I cannot see how wonderfulness Strawberry Panic is, please read the first three sentences of this paragraph again. Then again, until you can understand that I *do* like it. I just don’t think it’s as amazing as some do.)

Let’s start with the cover. You can see that the main character and her stalker roommate are depicted realistically. For eight year olds. However, they are actually 15.

And let’s enjoy the causal wear they are modeling. Exactly *which* part of the school uniform is that? Because clearly it’s only part of it.

But, hey, I’m told by dozens of people that this series is GREAT! Well, usually they say something like “its grate” – and no, I am not kidding or being mean. This is completely representative of the comments I’ve seen on Strawberry Panic.

DESPITE the fact that the fanbase is appalling, the second volume of Strawberry Panic has deviated quite remarkably from the anime and even from the first volume of the manga, which was primarily dedicated to light sexual harrassment which, if it had been guys doing it, would have made most fans of the series upset. But it was two girls, so many enjoyed it anyway. Just, not me.

In Volume 2, the Etoilesen, the competition for the school’s star couple, is about to begin. Unlike the anime, in which each school put up one couple, in the manga version many, many couples from all the schools appear to be eligible to compete. Of course the only two we care about are the Shizuma/Nagisa and Amane/Hikari pairs.

The competition opens with the swearing of vows of love and loyalty, all very wedding like. A couple clearly gets points on style, hence Amane’s swinging Hikari into her arms romantically (something also used in the anime, rather inexplicably if you hadn’t already read the manga. Luckily, I am getting the monthly issues of Dengeki G’s that the manga runs in, to cover just such situations. lol)

In the manga, it is Shizuma and Nagisa who are standing for the Etoile, not Tamao and Nagisa. Shion, president of Spica, is not above using dirty tricks to get Amane and Hikari into the Etoile position, so she secretly sends Nagisa info on Shizuma’s former partner. During the vow portion of the event, Shion asks Shizuma to swear that her love wholly and completely be given to Nagisa. After a moment of hesitation, Shizuma falls to her knees and makes the vow.

Nagisa is totally confused about everything which, for once, I can’t really blame her too much.

The first test is obviously designed to place Amane/Hikari above the pack with an awesomely stupid contest in which all the “cadets,” the younger partners, are shoved onto a platform on a tower, while the “ane,” the older partners, ride a steeplechase, save their princess from the tower and ride back. Of course tragedy strikes as both Hikari and Nagisa manage to fall. Of course they are saved. I mean, puh-leeze. We could hardly hope that they would be allowed to die so soon, more’s the pity. LOL Instead we are treated to Prince Amane and Etoile Shizuma at their knight-on-charger coolest. (And, btw, they are *still* an allegory for Heaven vs Hell. Just want to make the point. Amane all in white on her gray [white horses, for those of you non-horse people, are all “gray”] and Shizuma, all in black on her big black horse. [There’s no real black horses either. FYI.])

After the first round is over, there’s a little party at which Nagisa expresses her self-doubt. Shizuma restates her vow and the two seal their promise with a kiss.

End of volume.

I was pleasantly surprised to see a plot starting to develop in this volume – Kaname’s desire to win the Etoilesen has now been augmented with her open desire to win it *with* Amane (which leads to a great scene where Amane complains that if the two of them run together they’ll look like a Boy’s Love couple, which is countered by Shion saying that as a couple of Takarazuka Top Stars, they’d be a winning pair.) Kaname remains an EPL (Evil Psycho Lesbian), but Momomi is, at the moment, at least, not part of the equation. One hopes that she and Kaname will end up together.

Shizuma and Nagisa’s relationship is not being dragged unnecessarily through the angst fields as with the anime, and the kiss was neither sleazy nor servicey. In fact, for this series it was quite sweet. …I’m all for false hopes.

Art – 6 (too loli for me)
Story – 6
Characters – 5-6 depending on my mood
Yuri – 8
Service – 7

Overall – 6

It’s written by guys, for a fanboy audience. But I’ve seen (and enjoyed) worse. Not bad enough to be funny, not good enough to be “good,” it will no doubt be immensely popular when Seven Seas translates it.

Send to Kindle

20 Responses

  1. Anonymous says:

    You should copyright the term, “fandumb”. Everytime I see it, I just have to chuckle at how truly apropriate it is.

  2. I like to think that, long after I’m gone, the words and phrases I’ve coined (Yuri goggles, LFB, EPL, fandumb) will remain. :-)

  3. Anonymous says:

    It looks to me like they be might wearing gym clothes.

  4. Congratulations! You are the first person to miss the point! I’m sure you won’t be the last.

  5. TheBigN says:

    I really do want to see a post of some of the e-mails that you get. They sound like they are made by a lot of horny 12-15 year olds. :P

  6. Read the comments on any of the series that are clearly LFBN-intensive, like Kannazuki, or Eikyuu Alice, or anything Nanoha, that kind of thing.

  7. Sarah says:

    I actually did notice those comments, but didn’t think much about it at the time. XD. Maybe I’ll just be one of those people who likes the series but CAN spell.

  8. sarah, you are a rare and wonderful creature. :-)

  9. Reka says:

    I would absolutely love a review made up of real fandumb quotes. I have no doubt that the visible fanbase is largely stupid, but. It feels strange when you bash the fandumb, because I’ve only met cool people who like KnM. Really.

  10. Amaya says:

    Ah Strawberry Panic. Affectionately nicknamed Yuripanic. I haven’t read the manga (I actually stumbled upon this page searching for it) but I’ve watched the anime.
    Sure Nagisa is borderline unintelligent.
    Sure everyone likes her to my dismay.
    Sure the only confirmed males onscreen where Boshibaru the teddy bear and Star Bride the horse.
    Sure there’s something that makes it sound and look like a bad soap (LOL) but I still enjoyed it.
    Maybe because I adore Shizuma… (but that’s beside the point)
    It is pretty obvious why the fanbase for this would be… Mediocre but I liked SP! I Know lots of cool people who adored it and also liked KnM BUT they still managed to type correctly.
    At any rate I enjoyed reading your post.

  11. t is pretty obvious why the fanbase for this would be… Mediocre but I liked SP! I Know lots of cool people who adored it and also liked KnM BUT they still managed to type correctly.

    You think? I haven’t found that at all. SP fandumb is actually less coherent. Here’s an example of a comment that I received at the same time I received yours. Bear in mind that it was posted to my review od the SP 2 novel:

    hi i’m a quiet lil Yuri fan, can i ask if wen and wer r u going 2 publish the volume 2 episode of strawberry panic? tnx

    That’s the *second* comment I’ve recieved asking when I will make more SP….

  12. Random says:

    ^^ Fandumb?
    Well, on seeing so little SP fans that can actually spell, it makes me wonder if they are intentionally spelling worse that 8-year olds, and they are 8-year olds.. or worse, they are really old but can’s spell.
    Here’s another SP fan that can spell. I’ll admit that I like SP only because of Shizuma, Yaya, and Chikaru. I don’t like Nagisa.(I am joking, fellow fans. Or not).

  13. Anonymous says:

    Dude its was written by a girl!

  14. Anonymous says:

    I think maybe you’re missing the point of Strawberry Panic!…

  15. Anonymous – Nope. You might be, though. :-)

  16. Anonymous says:

    is there maybe a strawberry panic 2 cuz i saw the year it was made and tought of maybe they did a second series too

  17. No there is no sequel for the anime. Nor is there a third volume of the manga.

    This series is dead and done in Japan.

  18. Anonymous says:

    First of all the anime was not written by males, it was in fact a female. SP! was a great anime and I wish they would make a second season for it and I don’t like the fact they discontinued the manga, but what I really don’t get is why you have to hate on the fans of it. Insult the anime- sure that’s your opinion. Yet, you insult the people that watch it, that’s what’s slightly going over board. If all you can do is insult people for a single anime that you know they watch or insult them for not having the most God Given ability to have the best spelling in the whole world, then don’t insult at all- that makes you look like trash. I like Romance stories, that’s exacly what SP! is- A BIG ASS LOVE STORY- just with all females, nothing wrong with that either-of there’s a problem, please let me know. SP! isn’t relly -over- yet anyways because in June 2011, they would release Light Novels for it. Other then that, I don’t believe their doing anything else. I am a PROUD SP! FAN! No, i’m not a pervert. Yes, I do know how to spell. No, i’m not 8. Yes, I DO like romance stories.
    ~by Lucia Violeta

  19. @Lucia – If you take a look at the date of this post, you’ll see it was 2006. In the past five years my opinion has changed significantly. For an updated (but no less controversial) opinion, please read my most recent review of the manga omnibus: http://okazu.blogspot.com/2011/03/Yuri-manga-strawberry-panic-omnibus.html

    I will be honest. I still find it both amazing and bizarre that fans involve themselves so emotionally with characters that are clearly meant as parodies of other characters from other series. This series is over the top and unsubtle, and yet fans persist in taking it incredibly seriously.

    Nonetheless, I no longer loathe the series for itself, as you will see if you read my more recently review.

Leave a Reply