Hanako has traveled from far-away Japan to England, ostensibly in search of her favorite author. In Volume 1, Hanako is employed as a maid by Lady Alice, a beautiful, but always somehow sad, young daughter of a noble house.

In volume 2 of Goodbye, My Rose Garden, both Alice and Hanako are coming up against their feelings for one another, which are definitely not friendship, or appropriate to mistress and maid. And, possibly destructive of those feelings, both of the women are keeping secrets.  When Alice’s secret turns out to be related to Hanako’s, what could sunder them permanently, might also bring them closer.

When I reviewed the first Japanese volume of this series in spring 2019, I said, “I expected the volume to be a penny dreadful, with Victorian creepiness, but it’s actually a sad little story that I expect to see turned around in a pleasantly predictable ending.”

The “look at all the details I’ve researched!” feel of Volume 1 has settled down into a story that indicates plainly (if you understand the signs) that it is actually very much about gay life and literature here in Volume 2. References to Oscar Wilde are pretty blatant, but the references to Kate Chopin, author of The Awakening and Sarah Orne Jewett, author of The Country of the Pointed Firs, make it clear that this story is not just another costume drama, but intends on making a strong statement about feminism and queer existence in a time when the term feminism had only entered British speech a decade earlier and “gay rights” was long off.

Dr. Pepperco’s art has settled in and there’s more detail in expression over “stuff,” with a lingering sense of lecture on class relations.

Despite some potential for darkness, this volume ends up in a stronger place than it began, and we’re left waiting for the third volume expectantly hopeful.

Ratings:

Art – 7
Story – 7
Characters – 8
Service – 3
Yuri – 6

Overall – 7

Volume 3 is already available, so grab that climax today!

Thank you very much to Seven Seas for the review copy.