Archive for the Magazines Category


Yuri Manga: Yozora no Ouji to Asayake no Hime

March 10th, 2008

 Yozora no Ouji to Asayake no Hime (The Prince Night Sky and the Princess of the Sunrise) isn’t bad at all. For what it is. Which is another collection of stories from Yuri Hime magazine. Almost every story takes place in school, with the exception of the one Lady and her loyal ninja story. There are a few kisses and even the implication of more once or twice.

It’s not like this collection is bad – it isn’t. And there’s a general cheerful tenor. Nothing particular connects the stories – they remain exactly what they always were – Yuri one-shots. I didn’t dislike this collection – in fact, preferred the collection to the individual stories, as I am wont to do – but nothing really stands out here as exceptional. There’s happy Yuri, sad Yuri, slightly disturbing Yuri, funny Yuri, but it’s all much of a muchness. (Like Otome Cake, I mostly picked this volume up while I was in Tokyo because I was in Tokyo and it was there.) Like Last Uniform I don’t hate Hakamada’s work, but I can’t quite like it, either.

If you love her art or stories, then definitely get this book – I think it’s a damn sight better than Last Uniform. If you’re on the fence, save your money for something better like Rakuen no Jouken.

Ratings:

Art – 5
Characters – 5
Stories – 5
Yuri – 7
Service – 2

Overall – 5

As I glance over the collection I’m struck by an alternate opening to this review – “There are eight million stories in the Yuri City. These are a few of them.” I know very, very few of my readers will get that reference. I apologize. But it did strike me that way. ^_^





Yuri Manga: Voiceful (English)

February 27th, 2008

Books like Voiceful are exactly the reason the Yuricon definition of Yuri includes “intense emotional connections” between women. Because sometimes it’s not “love” yet, and hasn’t gotten anywhere near “desire” but it’s still some seriously intense bond that could easily become something more. (Another good example of that is Haibane Renmei, in which the circumstances preclude a love affair, but don’t stop Reki and Rakka from being intensely attracted to one another.)

Before I forget, thanks to Eric for sponsoring today’s review!

The creator, nawoko, says in her endnote that Voiceful is pretty far from Yuri. In one sense she is correct, but I think anyone who reads Kanae and Hina’s story will be able to see the Yuri, without the need for Yuri goggles.

For a summation of the content of the book, and my first impressions, please read my review of the Japanese edition. As I have been doing, today’s review will cover the adaptation by Seven Seas.

I think this is one of the best in Seven Seas’ Strawberry Line so far. The color page, the cover and the tones are clearer than usual. Towards the end of the volume, the stories get a little darker. The stories at the end of the volume are the earlier Yuri Shimai stories – I have no idea if that is related or not.

The translation is quite good. I know I wasn’t the only one who had some trouble with “Opening,” the final story (how ironic, huh?) and the translator did a very good job of making it make sense. The emotion between Kanae and Hina comes across beautifully, as well.

As always the editing and adaptation are smooth as silk and the honorifics remain in place. Nice job, everyone. ^_^

The book also contains some preview pages for First Love Sisters, as an “extra.” Since FSL is the other Ichijinsha book in the Strawberry Line so far, that seems like a natural fit. I’m interested to see if Seven Seas is able to (or wants to) pick up any further Yuri Hime comics – and which ones they might get.

Ratings:

Art – 7
Characters – 7
Story – 7
Yuri – 4
Service – 1, some slight undressedness

Overall – 7

While not the absolute best Yuri Hime collection Ichijinsha has put out, Voiceful is a nice way to ease into the genre. If you have a friend who isn’t really a big fan, or you know a young babydyke whose parents would object to Strawberry Panic (and what sane person wouldn’t? ^_^) Voiceful makes a gentle point of entry into the Yuri world.





Yuri Manga: Otome Cake

February 25th, 2008

Takahashi Mako’s Otome Cake is a very good example of the editor’s craft. Many writers and artists don’t really understand the need for an editor – their work should stand on its own merit, and who does this talentless ass think they are, anyway? ^_^; The editor for this volume was no ass, I can tell you that.

If you have been keeping up on my reviews of Yuri Shimai and Yuri Hime magazines, you’ll be aware of the fact that I have not ever been a fan of Takahashi’s work. The stories are filled with too many things I don’t like, for me to be able to see past them. The characters tend to look younger than their already too-young years, they are often suffering from mental illness, overtly or implicitly, they look like abused street rats and act like kids in war zones.

In short – creepy, violent, loli, with a light dash of Yuri for flavoring. (Not at *all* to my taste. I prefer my Yuri full-bodied and mature.)

However, Otome Cake isn’t bad. Somehow, the editor for this volume pulled out the least horrible of Takahashi’s stories, connected them with the thinnest possible thread of a theme on the connecting pages, and lo and behold, you have a collection that wasn’t bad, considering.

The cover has a gaggle of girls who all look like Charles Addams’ characters wielding a knife over a poor innocent cake. The dead eyes really help. ^_^

There’s nothing deep here – Yuri tends to be “I love her” and that’s about it, with the occasional kiss. Nothing after the happily ever afters – and not always happily ever after, in fact. The stories deal with mostly failed, first or unrequited loves, with a few exceptions, but the editor has chosen wisely and well, and the overall impression of the book isn’t as heavy and dark as Takahashi’s stories sometimes feel. The final story really helps – a light, cute story about two girls, a cake and a kiss on the school roof. It leaves us, if you will, with a pleasant taste in our mouths.

Ratings:

Art – It’s not really *bad*, but it makes me feel icky – 6
Story – 6
Yuri – 5
Service – 5

Overall – 6

Honestly, the thing I liked best was the cake being eaten in the pages separating the stories. :-)





Yuri Manga: Yuri Hime, Volume 11 Part 2

February 7th, 2008

Time for Part 2 of Yuri Hime Volume 11. Yay! Wielded with force, this book is big enough to leave a mark. :-)

Miura Shion’s essay on Yuri manga covers a few titles by Fujita Takumi, Goshuujin-sama ni Amai Ringo no Okashi and Yuki no Jou-ou. My thanks to Erin from Lililicious, who assisted me with deciphering Shion’s citations and reminding me that Lili has scanned in at least one of the stories from the former of the above books.

This is immediately followed by Morishima Akiko’s illustrated column, which this time takes us on a tour of manga shops around Tokyo where she and Chi-Ran recently did signings for their manga collection releases. (I’ve reviewed Morishima’s Rakuen no Jouken already. Chi-Ran’s Himitsu Shoujo to come.) I’m really sorry I missed all the signing dates by about a week. Looks like she had a blast. There are several notable things in her column – for one, she refers to these manga as “Yuri” (thank you very much, Morishima-san) and secondly, she comments on how there is yet to be a separate GL section in most of the bookstores, but there are a growing number of stores that are grouping the “Yuri” stuff together in at least small corners. If things keep up the way they are going now, I bet that by the time I get back to Japan, we’ll be seeing a shelf or two at least of GL in most stores.

In “Epitaph” Towa is suffering a little crisis of identity. She wants (it is apparent to me) to be more of an equal to Ash. And she’s jealous of the newcomer to what was her and Ash’s private place in the world. So she’s taking on more responsibility on her own, and simultaneously distancing herself from Ash. Towa’s task is to take a message to a musician, but finds herself drawn back time and time again, to feel the musician’s passion for her work, which is dedicated to a person she loves. Although the musician is clearly dying, she wants to make her mark. Ash joins Towa for her final visit – she’s been lonely without Towa, and finally realized what was going on. The musician is gone, but her legacy lives on.

The Apple Day Dream clothing shop is having an event and everyone is on edge. Mayu arrives and spends the entire time jealous of Kaoru’s attentions to the other women, but rebuffing her attentions to herself. When Kaoru is asked if they are going out and denies it so as to avoid conflict with Mayu, Mayu says yes, just to be contrary. How charming. The clothing designs are so nice. What a waste.

Hiyori Otsu once again takes a stride forward as one of my new fave artists. In the second chapter of “Clover” Sugiura comes every day to the bakery where Midori works. One day, Midori’s co-worker has suddenly quit, so Midori impulsively asks Sugiura to work there. And she does. As Christmas comes, they are busy selling cakes. They talk, as people do, about things they like. Midori wonders if Sugiura is seeing anyone. Sugiura broke up with someone not too long ago, so, not at the moment. As Sugiura describes her ex, it becomes apparent that she is referring to another woman. She then goes on to say that there is someone she likes, so, would Midori go out with her? Midori is embarrassed, but agrees. My favorite panel is the next day at school when Midori tells her classmate that she’s got a girlfriend. “Are you an idiot?” the classmate replies. So, they work together and go out. They kiss. Midori is thinking that this isn’t so bad, really, when two things happen. Her co-worker asks for his job back and a boy from her school stops by the shop with a love letter. Smiling, Sugiura gives Midori a “break-up kiss” and leaves both job and girlfriend. Midori realizes that she doesn’t *want* to break up and runs after Sugiura. When she catches up, she finds Sugiura crying. They patch it up, and continue to go out. The story ends with Midori visiting Sugiura’s home and learning that she doesn’t like sweets at all. She just liked the girl at the bakery. :-) A great story, with a little bit of a story past the “happily ever after” part – just enough to make it all really work.

Haruna’s former crush, her sempai, has returned to Tsunojyo, there’s a rumor going around that Touko-sensei is leaving and the strange girl that has befriended Teshigawara is moving. All three crises are soon resolved in the final chapter of “Hatsukoi Shimai.” Finally, finally, finally, Touko and Akiho kiss. That’s really all I care about. I’m so going to have to write another story for them. :-) Chika and Haruna live happily ever after, and so do Kirika and Miyu, presumably. And all the potential cliff-hanger crises like Akiho’s relationship with her sister and Kirika’s fall simply disappear.

And now to the “rant” I mentioned yesterday in regards to “Aoi Shiro.” I obviously don’t know what editorial decisions are being made, but am I alone in thinking that Yuri Hime is becoming a big lump of dropped crises? In Simoun, the story was just beginning when it was ended. “Aoi Shiro” had just got going – I mean, the first three chapters were practically all introductory. And now this – we had about three or four completely disappearing cliffhangers/climaxes in Hatsukoi Shimai. I honestly don’t know if it’s editorial pressure to not let a series run too long, or if there are other factors that force stories to be cut short. In every one of the above cases, it feels very much like the story was just stopped. It may just be that they are trying to keep things light. I simply have no idea. But it’s starting to feel like a pattern. And it’s making me jumpy, because as a crisis/confrontation/climax arrives, the story just sort of peters out.

Anyway, enough discussion – let’s move on.

“Ameiro Kouchakan Kandan” continues on it’s path of non-crisis filled happiness. Having determined that they were both pretty hopeless without one another, Seriho and Sarasa have decided to visit some other cafes in hopes of coming up with ideas to invigorate their business. Seriho finds herself enjoying watching Sarasa eat – a sure sign of complete besottedness. :-) As they end their day, Seriho thanks Sarasa for the date, which flusters Sarasa, who thought they were out on business. Seriho corrects her – they were, for the first half of the day, the second half was their first date. Tee hee.

“Reijin” by Chi-Ran, starts with a different point of view than usual. In this story, the protagonist hates women. And she doesn’t hate them any less when the school doctor hits on her. But the seeds have been sown and despite her reluctance – nay, abhorrence – of her own sex, at the end, our protagonist admits defeat by asking the doctor her name.

In Takahashi Mako’s “Yuki no Ashimoto” we watch a girl find her adored sempai’s cell phone and answer it when it rings. As a result, she gets to meet Misaki-sempai face to face. Misaki says it’s a fateful meeting, as the story ends.

Hisako is a writer. The other girls make fun of her writing, but Sayako defends her. For this, and many other reasons, Hisako writes a love letter to Sayako in Hakamada Mera’s “Love Letter.” The wind rips the letter away from Hisako, and delivers it to Sayako. Fate strikes once again. :-)

The last story, “Nightmare Syndrome” by Natsuneko, is helpfully labeled “Vampire Love” for the two people who missed it. lol Alicia has been planning on getting her revenge against sexy vampire Berger for her father’s death. Only, Berger sort of stops her by being, you know, a sexy vampire. While Alicia is staying in Berger’s mansion, they are attacked by Reynolds, who conveniently was the real culprit in Alicia’s father’s death. Alicia, Berger, and the eye-patch-wearing maid all survive to live eternally as happy sexy lesbian vampires. The plot is pretty well done to death, but I really, really like Natsuneko’s art and the action-filled panels. I am very much looking forward to any forthcoming collection of this artist’s work. Her (I’m assuming here) stuff is fun, with a pleasant touch of off-beat edginess. And her sexy lesbians are sexy.

All that’s left is the Petite Yuri Hime, the extra mini-comic included with this volume. As they announced in their press release, this was a combination of artists from Yuri Hime, Yuri Hime S and Yuri Hime: Wildrose, with the common theme of “New Year’s” although there are exceptions, like the Alice in Wonderland chapter of “Hatsukoi Shimai.” Some of the stories are cute, some are funny. The winner for “made me laugh out loud” was a funny but gross little short called “Girls Don’t Cry” which centered on character snorting noodles out her nose. It was low humor, but it *was* funny. :-)

As I said originally, this volume was so large that, if you include the Petite mini-comic, you have 36 comics to read, plus essays and commentary and letters and the like. I enjoyed more than I didn’t. Above all, there was Touko-sensei and Akiho finally getting together and the greatest chapter of Strawberry Shake Sweet ever.

And now that I have finally reviewed it, I’m going to have to go back and read it all over again. Excellent, excellent volume. May we see it go bi-monthly soon.

Overall – 8





Yuri Manga: Yuri Hime, Volume 11 Part 1

February 6th, 2008

This book is so huge, I have to get it out of the pile o’stuff to review, which is once again dangerously tall. The good news is – this book is *huge*!

Yuri Hime Volume 11 is about 460 someodd pages of Yuri goodness, plus an extra mini publication, Petite Yyuri Hime as an omake. There’s new stories, and continuing stories and a few series that end. Like all anthologies, you may not like everything in it – there are some stories I certainly do not care for – but with *so* much inside, there’s bound to be something you like. :-)

This volume starts off with “Sweet Peach,” a news series. Kisaragi Touka is in the infirmary and is a bit freaked out/intrigued by the doctor. And she can’t help but wonder who the mysterious woman in the infirmary is. She need not have fretted about that, because on the way home Touka is attacked by energy creatures of some kind and the doctor – now dressed as a maid, and the other woman – now with pointy animal ears and a Big-Ass Sword TM, save her. The doctor-maid take a few licks of the Touka-sicle and the swordswoman kisses her and takes her …somewhere safe. With no explanation, of course. But she has a magical mouse for company at least. To be continued – hopefully, to make some sense. :-)

“Tokimeki Mononoke Gakuen” ups the service a few notches with this issue’s chapter o’bizarre. A kappa and a two-mouthed woman fall in love. Only, the kappa falls in love with the giant mouth on the back of the two-mouthed girl’s head. The front mouth on the face, is jealous, but the kappa only kisses the back mouth. So…the face decided that she wants the kappa’s lower lips. Irritatingly, the mouth in the back takes those too. And the whole time this is going on, Arare is trapped in the tree above, forced to sit through this extremely extreme situation. See, she was playing hide and go seek when the two below started to…and now… Kiri shows up, gets the gist pretty fast and asks if Arare want a little sumthin’-sumthin’ for herself. Of course not, don’t be silly, etc, etc. But Kiri kisses Arare anyway. To be continued, but never to be less freaky. :-)

This chapter of “Strawberry Shake Sweet” is the BEST CHAPTER EVER. *EVER*. And because it is, I can’t tell you a damn thing about it without spoiling it rotten. So here we go – prepare to be spoiled rotten. If you do not wish to be, skip to the second set of asterisks.

Preparing for massive spoilage…

***

The chapter begins with Julia and Ran’s staged kiss in what is a really nicely executed series of panels. The concert goes on, but Julia and Ran take themselves off to change. Julia, trying to convince herself again, talks about the kiss as good work, just a job, etc and Ran loses it. She blurts out her feelings about Julia. Julia being Julia, tries to convince herself that really Ran didn’t mean it that way. But there no putting cats back in bags, as we know. Watching the concert from above together, Julia *finally* tells Ran what she feels. And then immediately regrets it. As she hems and haws and thinks the usual “well, that’s it” Ran says her name. Julia looks up to find herself being kissed soundly by Ran. The two of them sort of wander their mental way to the place where they realize that yes, indeed, they do have the same feelings for one another…and Julia gets a grade-A nosebleed. Thus completely ruining the mood. LOL

Meanwhile, in Tokyo, Saeki gets “a really bad feeling about this.”

***

More craziness to come, but seriously. Best chapter ever. Would that all “funny” Yuri be this good. And seriously, I have got to work on a short fan letter to send Hayashiya-sensei. Because she’s bring me a lot of joy these days. :-)

Morishima Akiko’s signature round, snuggly art fills “Star Princess”; a short, no-context piece about a girl who considers herself a prince to her friend’s princess.

“Creo the Crimson Crises” continues, but I’ve sort of stopped caring. Suoh is so weepy and soppy, and she appears to be getting smaller with each chapter. She’s practically a pocket pet at this point. One of Suoh’s school friends turns out to be a raging demon who, in “defense” of Suoh, tries to defeat Creo. Doesn’t work. The flaw with this kind of story is that Suoh, whom we are all fighting over, is as interesting as a rag. It’s a pretty common flaw in anime and manga and for me, it’s insurmountable.

Kiko loves Ohzawa in “Koi Wazurai Lovesick.” She tries to get the point across, but Ohzawa’s being a little dense. Frustrated with Ohzawa’s inability to understand what she means, and how much Ohzawa’s dating a guy from another class hurts her, Kiko has to find a way to make the point. She makes the point by kissing Ohazawa, then walking away. Ohzawa comes running up to return the kiss – and the emotion.

“Nanami to Misuzu” remains the hysterical confabulation of animal ears, siscon, maid and other fetishes that it always is.

Last year, Ichijinsha ran a “new artist” contest. The results of that contest are published – with an example of the art, a synopsis of the story and the exceedingly generous prizes offered. The winner has been published in this issue of Yuri Hime.

The winning story, “Daisuki” by Hanatsu Yaya, is the next story in the magazine. It’s…grim. A girl who is the punching bag for her entire school is in love with and lives with a girl who is actually a dragon. While the art in “Daisuki” is reminiscent of many josei artists and not at all bad, and the story has some unique twists, it is not a happy story.

Following that are lots of color pages which contain advertising and the next chapter of “Aoi Shiro.” Which turns out to be the last chapter of “Aoi Shiro.” Like the Simoun manga was to the anime, this is meant to be read as a complement to the game. There is no complete story being told. I kind of feel that that’s a bit of a cop-out. (I’ll pick up that thread again later, so let me hold off on the rant for now.) But, for what it’s worth, this manga kind of actually sets up the game, as far as I can tell. The game’s main character, Shouko, is introduced and given a back story. Sawacchi and Shouko learn to stand side by side and Momo sort of drops back to supporting actor. It’s a pat, but pleasant end – and presumably, a pat, but pleasant opening to the game.

I think I’m going to stop here, but there’s a lot more to go, so don’t forget to check back tomorrow – and thanks to everyone who continues to support Yuri by buying Yuri Hime and other Yuri Manga. :-)