Archive for the Magazines Category


Yuri Manga: Yuri Shimai 4

August 4th, 2004

Yuri Shimai has just released the fourth issue and at first glance, it may be the best one so far. In fact, there are so many things worth noting, I’ll probably do this is two entries. Right off the top, there is much less lolicon than usual – in general there is a *slighty* older feel to the stories. It isn’t much, but I’ll take it!

(Let me just stop here and recommend that, if you are purchasing Yuri Shimai, take the time to fill out the opinion card that comes inside. It’s not a bad thing for them to know that they have a western audience, and our opinions are at least as interesting as anyone else’s.)

So, the new issue begins with a 32-page, with color, manga adaptation of Koi Shimai, a name which might ring a bell or two if you read this blog regularly. Koi Shimai is the name of the original CD Drama put out by the publisher of Yuri Shimai. If you remember from my past reviews, Koi Shimai is the story of Chika and Haruna – how they meet and fall in love, face trials and tribulations (which consist of lots of twisted ankles, scraped knees and one seductive teacher.) In this manga adaptation, the same story is retold, but there’s some significant rewriting from the Drama CD, which gives both the characters and story a little more depth. I’m looking forward to seeing how things turn out – in the manga version Haruna is not at *all* the same person she is in the drama CD. Instead of being insipid and passive, she has become aloof and cold, so Chika will have a much harder time getting through her barriers.

Another interesting thing to note about Koi Shimai is that the artist and writer are the same ones who are doing the manga adaptation of Maria-sama ga Miteru – so the style of the story and art are very familiar.

Following closely upon the heels of Koi Shimai is the most recent chapter of that wacky love comedy, Strawberry Shake. Teen idol Julia is no closer to admitting her feelings for Ran-chan, and now the story has expanded into a love polygon – only it’s not shy and sexy Ran-chan that everyone is fighting over, it’s the uptight manager, Sawaki. This issue was, as usual, quite silly, but as long as Julia has no competition for Ran everyone is, IMHO, welcome to fight over the manager. ^_^ And it’s kind of a funny complication, because it is the manger who is effectively keeping Julia and Ran apart.

One of the more amusing things about Strawberry Shake is the “all the girls are in love with each other” quality of the story. Julia loves Ran, who loves her back, and the hair stylist and assistant manager are both in love with the manager, while the other girl idol is in love with the hair stylist…and the random visual girl-band members are two couples. The story is very reminiscent of Kat William’s work, partially from the wackiness, and partially from the complex of intertwining relationships. The same could be said, of course, about Koi Shimai, where all the characters have some relationship with or impact upon the primary relations…and even more so about Morinaga Milk’s ongoing lesbian high school saga.

And, on that note, I’m going to cover the next entry into that saga next time. Tune back in to hear more on the new Yuri Shimai!





Yuri Manga: Yuri Shimai 3

May 11th, 2004

It’s that time again! The folks at Sun Publishing have released the newest volume of Yuri Shimai.

Once again Yuri Shimai offers a beautiful color cover, along with short narrative on the characters inside the book, a few color posters and about half a dozen or so short girl’s love manga stories that take place exclusively in middle and high schools, since, as we all know, lesbians die at 18 or become bi in order to survive.

On the eye-rolling side of the equation, many of the characters are still mis-matched size types – i.e., one character is teeny and looks 10 and the other *almost* looks her age and is at least a foot taller. This will never cease to creep me out, because of the implications of this particular convention – the constant use of oneesama by the younger-looking characters only makes it worse for me.

However, that having been once again beaten into the ground, there are many positives to this issue, and some hope for future ones.

The first thing one notes upon opening this volume is that the color pages in the beginning include yuri-centric write-ups of several anime that were notibly yuririffic. In fact, I had to laugh, because we were certainly following them all closely on the Yuricon Mailing List.  Jubei-chan 2, ROD The TV, Kaleido Star and Yami to Boushi to Hon no Tabibito were all represented with full-color pictures of some of the key Yuri moments. So, that was really fun, right off.

Secondly, one of the best stories in the book so far, Strawberry Shake, has been running since Yuri Shimai’s inception and it has not only been slightly different, but also funny and wacky in a very not-annoying way. This volume it gets several color pages of its own and a slightly longer chapter. In this chapter, Julia has decided to separate her personal and professional life in order to get to know Ran better. Of course, hilarity ensues, only this time, it’s actually kind of funny.^_^ When they do eventually get together, Julia and Ran will make a great couple.

Also continuing from the last volume is a story by Kita Kanno. “Under the Noon Sun” is about two dysfunctional schoolgirls who find themselves as roommates. I found this one typical and disappointing. I am officially announcing my dislike for the following plot complications:

Fevers caused by standing in the rain, or sleeping in the cold, or random who knows why-type reasons that have nothing to do with the real reasons people get fevers

Amnesia

Food stuck on a person’s face as a substitute for a kiss

Warming someone’s body up with a naked body (yes, I know it’s a real thing…it still makes an utterly crappy PC.)

Losing weight on crash diets

Breast grabbing for whatever reason

Falling on someone, completely sprawled across them, full-body

Cramming for exams

Licking someone’s finger to stop the bleeding as a substitute for kissing

Any PC that has to do with schoolgirl’s skirts, bathing suits or “three size”.

These are all utterly without merit and need to be removed whole from shoujo manga, in my curmudgeonly, yet humble, opinion. And yes – it *is* possible to have a good story without these.

But back to the point – in “Under the Noon Sun” one of the characters gets…I kid you not…a fever from a cold, because the other one crawled into bed with her the night before becuse she was cold. I mean, really.

On a more positive note, the lesbian bug continues to spread throughout the high school in the next installment of Morinaga Milk’s all-girl school series. This chapter is entitled “Someday This Love” and it is unfortunately yet *another* stupid-reason-induced-fever based plot, but is otherwise kind of cute. More importantly, the next Morinaga Milk story looks to have at least one real kiss coming, and *that* I’m looking forward to.

The last volume of Yuri Shimai seemed to have an inordinate amount of breast-grabbing; this one, everyone is coming down with unreasonable fevers. It’s like a weird group mind, that so many of the authors use the same stupid plot devices in any given volume.

Nonetheless, with the usual book, movie, manga, game, anime and fan work reviews, Yuri Shimai is really shaping up to be a valuable resource and, in some case, an interesting read. So here’s thumbs up for this issue and hopes that the next one, due out in July, will be even better. ^_^





Yuri Manga: Yuri Shimai, Issue 1 and 2

January 26th, 2004


What’s really, really hot right now? Well, with the advent of Yuri-filled schoolgirl romance in Maria-sama ga Miteru , schoolgirls are hot, hot, hot. So hot that manga and anime are popping up left and right with a bazillion versions of the same old sempai/kohai romance, over and over.

Do I sound jaded? I admit, I kind of feel it. A steady diet of mediocre high school lesbian drama has worn me down a little and I’m a little less enthused by the new yuri than I had expected to be. It’s great to see more Yuri and all, but does it ALL have to be high school confessions that lead nowhere? (To be fair, it’s not Marimite‘s fault – it’s all the knock-offs and me-toos that have me cringing. And the subject of today’s review is *not* to blame, since it came out last summer, well before the Great Schoolgirl Rush of ’04.

Yuri Shimai is definitely the front runner in the Yuri manga category at the moment. Published quarterly by SunSun Magazine (the folks who bring you June magazine) Yuri Shimai is now on its second issue. While the second issue of YS suffers a very little from “second album” syndrome, there’s much more good here than bad…although, as I say, I’d had my fill of schoolgirls by the end. Since girls in school uniform…indeed women under the age of 25 or so…do nothing for me, I get bored pretty quickly of one teen romance after another. You know, lesbians *do* survive to adulthood…

That having been said, there is much to recommend Yuri Shimai to any Yuri fan. For one thing, it’s very slick. Nice color covers, about a dozen color pages and inserted color posters make both issues of Yuri Shimai worth the purchase price. Sun Sun has got the money to drop into this book – and it shows. Production-wise, we couldn’t ask for anything better.

The stories are variable in art and content, but most are sweet and charming. A few transcend the usual Yuri conventions to create interesting characters and motivations. One of my complaints about the second issue was the overuse of breast-grabbing as a plot point. I don’t know, maybe Japanese girls do go around doing that, bit it always seems forced and unreal to me.

There’s at least one continuing story, “Strawberry Shake”. So, get together with a few friends, open an account with Amazon Japan and *buy* the magazine, or this one too, will go the way of Mist, Anise, Phryne and all other lesbian-oriented Japanese publications, which have become defunct. Because, in the end, the only thing that talks is money.)

Another useful and fun part of YS is the “Vox Populi” section, which outlines manga, anime, novels, movies and games with Yuri content – I steal freely from this section to fill my shelves at home. ^_^ Additionally, the second issue has an encouraging fan art section – one hopes that they received so much mail that a switch to monthly may one day be in the making. And the second issue provides a form for yuri doujinshi/manga artists to send in their work to be reviewed. One day you might see Rica ‘tte Kanji!? or Yuri Monogatari covered in those pages! (Now, wouldn’t that be cool?)

Ultimately, time will tell whether YS has any staying power, but even despite my eventual longing for a story about a lesbian chain gang, I know that I’ll be keeping my fingers crossed. ^-^