Archive for the Now This Is Only My Opinion Category


Guide to Yuri on Afterellen.com

July 25th, 2007

Lesbian pop culture site Afterellen.com has published a “Guide to Yuri” written by yours truly. It’s nothing you folks don’t already know, trust me. This was more for folks who don’t know where to start.

I cover a lot of series and I missed a lot more (only had 1500 words to play with,) so *please* feel free to comment with more series that I didn’t cover in the article.

The only things I ask are that you 1) make sure there’s actually Yuri in it and you’re not talking something that needs Yuri Goggles, ’cause we don’t want to waste people’s time and; 2) try to stick with series that are licensed for western release – giving a one-line description is a good idea too, so people know what they are looking at. Remember, tastes differ. That’s why I covered as many types of anime and manga in my article as I could.

The more interest the article gets, the more likely it is that they will have me back to write more. Tell your friends, make those comments! :-)

(Ironically, as I cannot access Afterellen.com from work, it is thanks to loyal reader Derek that I know that they published the “Guide” today – it’s a day ahead of schedule. :-) Thanks Derek!)





Why Yuri Paddles are Stoopid and a tidbit of Otakon 2007, Day 2

July 23rd, 2007

$35.

That’s how much a small paddle-shaped piece of wood that says “Yuri” costs.

For $35, you can buy 4 books from ALC Publishing, or register for Yuricon’s 2007 “Yurisai” event – and still have money over for lunch.

You can share the books with friends, review them, talk about them with the folks on the Yuricon Mailing List. Or you can come to the Yurisai, hang out with Rica Takashima and other Yuri notables, watch Yuri anime, learn to make Yuri AMVs, draw Yuri manga, read Yuri manga and doujinshi at our Library.

You can carry a Yuri Paddle around. But only at anime cons, really. And not at Yuricon (or Yaoi-Con, for that matter – they have also banned them as nuisances.)

Yuri Paddles support Hen Da Ne, a nice group of guys who make most of their money selling doujinshi. With apologies to them, they do not make Yuri, nor do they support most of the Yuri doujinshi circles, because they buy primarily highly pornographic doujinshi, perpetuating the “Yuri is porn” thing. ALC Publishing remains the only all-Yuri publisher in the world – we seek out and publish women, lesbians, who draw stories of women in love, rather than women having sex on one another with unrealistic (and to me, at least, disgusting) gouting bodily fluids of undefined source.

Lastly, carrying a Yuri paddle is like carrying a sign that says “I am sexually immature.” (True story – at recent con, a guy asked if he could take a picture of me holding a paddle and I refused. He asked why; I commented that Yuri paddles as signs that says “I am sexually immature” to which he said, “I am sexually immature.” “But I’m not,” I replied.)

The bottom line is, those paddles are useless. They will not get you laid. They support Yuri in no way. What they do is take your money and funnel it AWAY from Yuri.

So, please. Don’t. If you want to support Yuri, buy licensed anime and manga – we have a long list of great Yuri-flavored series on the Yuricon Store. Or any ALC books or “I Love Yuri” items (money from which goes directly to making more Yuri manga and running events.) Don’t buy Yuri paddles.

***

And, for reasons I can’t go into (but which are perfectly legitimate, trust me!) I ended up in the 4chan panel last night. This is particularly amusing considering last weekend’s “Why does /u/ hate Erica Friedman?” thread. (I was going to post to that and insult me better than they were, but I just didn’t care that much. “I hate Erica Friedman because she killed my sled dog!”)

Anyway, I just want to say, I have never been closer to being bored to death in my life. If someone had killed me, I would have considered it a respite from the tedium. The panel was an awesome display of just how much apes can mimic human behavior.

***

I’ll try and type up the rest of my weekend when I get home tomorrow. Lots of good, lots of bad and lots of people with questionable fashion sense. ;-)





Guest Review Guidelines

July 12th, 2007

2021 Update: Guest Reviews on Okazu are paid at what is currently an industry standard. As a result we are more strict about Guest Review applications and submissions. Please read and follow the process below carefully: 

If you would like to write a Guest Review for Okazu, please begin here before you contact us!

1) If you have never been a Guest Reviewer before, please email me *first*. Introduce yourself. “Hello, my name is _____ and I am writing to discuss a possible Guest Review for /name of series and media/.” Anime, manga or games only please. Games and Visual Novels are especially welcome. 

Please send a request for *one* series to review. (Folks have been known to send suggestions for multiple series. Please do not. Thank you.)

Please also do a quick search using the search function on the righthand sidebar to see if the media you’re contacting me about has already been reviewed. We have a lot of content on Okazu, we may have covered it already. ^_^

 

If you have previously Guest Reviewed and are suggesting a review, you can begin here:

2) Suggest a series that you have legitimately purchased or watched on a legal stream. No subs or scans or games that were downloaded illicitly. Remember, at Okazu, we support the industry and the creators. 

3) What should follow is a short discussion of *why* that series suitable as a review topic for Okazu – i.e., where’s the Yuri or Queer content and why it is of interest to Okazu readers. This is the meat of your pitch so please, I beg you, keep your email relevant. We are most interested in Japanese and other East Asian popular culture content, but are open to western popular culture, or relevant non-fiction reviews.

Spell check it, make sure the grammar is correct. It is upon this section that I will be making my decision. (This is unnecessary if I have specifically solicited a review for a series from you.)

 

If you have have been solicited to write a review you can start here:

4) DO NOT EMAIL ATTACHMENTS. I hate, loathe and abhor attachments. When you email the review, you MUST send it as inline text, so I can cut and paste it. If you make me open an attachment I will be very grouchy. 500 words is average for a review, but we’re not counting, so you don’t have to be anal. If you can write a succinct review in a couple hundred words, feel free, or go longer if you have a lot to say.

5) Please use the format I use for Okazu and include ratings as I do. The format is, roughly: 

– Personal Intro and links to your relevant sites.
– Series Intro and
Synopsis.
– Notable Items of Interest. If there are any. For instance, this is where you might discuss the art or a theme, etc.
Discussion of the Yuri/Queer content
– Ratings.

If it is an obscure, out-of-print or hard-to-find series, please include a cover picture or a link to a cover picture. If it is currently available I’ll use the official cover art.

Ratings on Okazu are from 1-10 on categories:
Art –
Story –
Characters –
Service (level of salaciousness) –
Yuri  –
Overall –

You can also add in ratings for notable qualities like music for an anime. Ratings may be as capricious as you like. The Overall score does not have to be an average of the other scores. The Overall score is a general effect/overall impression score.

 

6) Please proofread your review before you send it. Have a friend proofread it or read it out loud. 

Lastly – being a Guest Reviewer on Okazu is an honor. I do not bestow it lightly. I may reject your review. It is most likely not personal. Either I did not feel that the series was worthy, or your review needed improvement or I want to review that anime/manga myself or something else. Please don’t take it personally. 

7) If your review is accepted payment will be made through Paypal. Include your Paypal email with your review. ^_^ We won’t demand formality. If you send out invoices for your own records, that’s fine.

We welcome Guest Reviewers on Okazu and look forward to working with you! Thank you to all our Okazu Patrons for making it possible to pay Guest Writers the industry standard!





Now This is Only My Opinion the Fourth

May 31st, 2007

Here we go…

1. What is the harshest criticism you received for Shoujoai ni Bouken (and/or Saiyuu no Ryokou), and how did you respond to it?

A very sweet fan accosted me over why Yuriko, although Japanese, has blonde hair and blue eyes. My stock answer has always been, “because I like blondes” but that didn’t satisfy her. So I tried to explain that it was like a manga, you know – crazy hair color…but she was no less unhappy with that. At that point I was out of reasons and she started to get insistent that I have a better, more sensible reason. After nearly half an hour of this, I ended up protesting feebly that it was fiction and she’d just have to accept it.

 

2. What do you consider to be the most irritating and pointless pairing in all of Yuri?

All of the ones that don’t make any sense.

 

3.What’s your favourite piece of fanfiction of all time (that you or someone you know didn’t write)?

Case of the Philosophers Ring. Sherlock Holmes meets Aleister Crowley. It’s out of print now, sadly. It’s a total wank. But at the time I read it, it seemed brilliant. The key to fanfic is to write in a fandom that has gone out of copyright – Sherlock Holmes fanfic writers have all the luck.

 

4. Pepsi or Coke?

Nice cup of tea.

 

5. Meeting eyes across a crowded room or dark smoky bar?

Caught you looking at me in the stacks in the library.

 

6. Where did you meet your wife?

Mrs. Welty’s American Indians class in middle school.

 

7. What advice would give to another human being?

Don’t take yourself seriously. Never, EVER use absolutes. It’s not personal.

 

8. So, who is this “A. Niles Bocon” person, and why are you using his email?

Obscure alchemist, best known among devotees for developing a foolproof system for turning gold into lead.

 

9. If you could have a plushie of any one character (not of your own creation, but any other book/anime/manga/movie/ova, etc are fair ground) who would it be, and why?

A talking Friday Monday plushie complete with pathetic evil laughter. If I can do real people, I’d want an Adam Smith (author of Wealth of Nations) so I could beat the shit out of it every once in a while.

 

10. What kind of world will we be living in? in 50 years? 80 years? (or the kind of world you see yourself in) Apocalypse?

The same. Only with slight differences.

 

11. What is your favourite anime/manga that doesn’t have even the slightest trace of yuri in it?

Hands down, no hesitation, Patlabor.

 

12. What do you usually have for breakfast?

Half a bagel with cottage cheese and coffee.

 

13. Where is that “Nonsense! I don’t agree” picture from?

http://xroads.virginia.edu/~class/am485_98/graham/psych.html
There’s no source for it on that page, though.

 

14.What is the stupidest thing you have ever done?

Followed a kid we didn’t know into the souq in Cairo to go to a store that (hopefully, supposedly) sold belly dancing stuff, because the wife wanted to shop. If he had led us straight to a slaver, no one would have ever known what happened to us.

 

Fnord?

Fnord.

 

15. What’s your middle name? (if you refuse to respond for reasons of identity theft, I’ll understand)

Lee – I’m named after a grandfather and a great-grandfather.

 

16. Why do people still use Yahoo! and AOL? (or more appropriately, why did they ever use them in the first place)

Free and OMG! Free CDS!

 

17. Should i really be concerned about sodium benzoate in soda pop?

Among other things. To be on the safe side, stick with water, or failing that, grain alcohol.

 

18. What is your favorite place on Earth? What is your least favorite?

Most favorite: My house, followed closely by Ikebukuro, Tokyo and Brecon, Wales. Least favorite: Ohio and Florida.

 

19. Have you ever been convicted of a felony?

No. Not even a misdemeanor. But if I did, I would hardly tell you, would I?

 

20. Do you find that people respond differently to you when you talk about your “wife” as opposed to having simply referred to her as your “girlfriend”? Or did you always just call her your wife?

No one really reacts around here these days. Except to say, “what’s her name?”

 

20. When are you going to summarize next Marimite novels?

When I get around to it.

 

21. Serious. I have been thinking for some time and come up with a theory: Any series that markets itself _primarily_ as ‘yuri’ or ‘yaoi’ is going to be, at best, second rate – for the same reason that we are knee deep in asinine Harem animes. For example, Utena contains a strong yuri component, but that isn’t what the series is about primarily; similarly, Tokyo Babylon contains a strong yaoi component, but, again, it isn’t what it is about primarily. And both of those are first-rate. Yet, anything that tries to base itself _primarily_ on that will, at best be second-rate – witness Simoun, Devil Lady.

Your Thoughts?

I think I pretty much disagree with all your specific comments while mostly agreeing with your premise. I think Simoun and Devilman Lady were brilliant – and the latter was in no way marketed as Yuri. Nor do I think Tokyo Babylon was anything like good. I found it inexplicable and stultifying. I also disagree that marketing is why we are knee-deep in harem anime. The reason we are knee deep in harem anime is that the large bulk of anime fans are guy who dream of being surrounded by girls with crushes on them.

I don’t think there have been very many good Yaoi/Yuri anime because there aren’t really that many *good* anime in general. It’s a matter of percentages. And, apparently, taste.

 

21. First Spurious question: What the most annoying type of Yuri fanfiction out there?

Anything that pairs two characters together that shouldn’t/couldn’t/can’t be together. I don’t think a story has to be realistic, or even possible – but it should be plausible. Pairing two characters that show no sign of any feelings for each other is just…weird.

 

22.Do you believe in fundamental gender differences between men and women? If so, then how?

I believe in fundamentals differences between people. And similarities. It’s awfully complex.

 

23. What yuri manga do you believe would make a great feature film? Maybe specifically an American feature film?

The Japanese can make movies of their manga, because they don’t mind nothing happening, or strange pacing. For any manga to be made into an American live-action, it would essentially have to be rewritten completely, thus rendering the question moot. I’d personally find Maya no Souretsu to be a great over-written, campy, creepy, late-night horror movie, though.

 

24. I’m scared of getting old, really, I feel life can have gruesome ways of pressing, so.. any advice/info/insult on this?

Getting older rocks. And really…what are you going to do about it anyway? Worry about something you can do something about.

 

25. Why do you think boys like Yuri? (and I’m talking about non-hentai yuri)

Girls are pretty, soft and smell nice.

 

26. Based on their characterization, what do you think are the chances of Sachiko and Yumi ending up together (not necessarily in the novels themselves but at least in the imaginary “after the novels” time)?

Zero.

 

27. here’s a question I’ve been asking myself for some time, and I’ll use this occasion to ask it to you. I’m sorry if someone already asked it before.
As a fanfiction reader and writer, what do you think about the concept of throwing the cast of a comedy in a dark and dramatic story?

The wife and I did it in reverse once. ^_^

Writing “hand of god” tragedy is the easiest thing to do. Writing comedy is hard – writing farce that’s even remotely amusing is next to impossible. Writing comedic characters in angsty situations is what nearly every fanfic writer in the world does to start.

 

28. What does IMHO mean?

It means “In my humble opinion” but I’m not likely to ever be accused of being humble, so in my case I use the alternate “In my honest opinion” which is completely true.

 

Well…you know, I was kind of disappointed with your questions. Not very funny, really. You all need to go back to comedy improv class. For the ones I thought weren’t going to be fun to answer, I asked my wife to answer them instead. Because *that* is comedy. ^_^

 





Time for Utter Nonsense!

May 28th, 2007

You may have noticed that I’ve been doing reviews and posts something like 6 days a week recently. Or maybe you haven’t. But I have. :-) And now, I am tired. I am also beginning the last couple of weeks of production work on Yuri Monogatari 5 (which, btw, is going to be brilliant. And I’m not just saying that.) And I start a new job tomorrow. So…no reviews for a couple of days while I reconstruct my daily schedule and figure out where and what I am doing.

In the meantime, as I have done the last few times I needed a break, I am once again taking questions on anything – life, the universe, Yuri, my favorite flavor of jellybean, whether jelly bean is one word or two, Maria-sama ga Miteru, Yuriko, anything. Feel free to post your questions here in the comments field, or email them to me at [email protected]. I do not promise to answer every question, but I’ll do my best. The better the question, the better the answer, usually. Hint, hint. ;-)

The last few times we did this, it was a total scream – I can’t wait for your questions this time!