While Volume 4 of Kininatteru Hito Ga Otoko Janakatta, Volume 4 (気になってる人が男じゃなかった) was one of the most-anticipated manga to arrive in my house, it’s also something that both my wife and I are following online, so we are more or less tuning in, rather than seeing it “finally.”

Volume 4 finishes the “prom” arc, in which Mitsuki and Aya finally give up any pretense of “maybe.” If you haven’t been following along on any of Arai-sensei’s social feeds, then all I want to say about this is…it’s a good kiss. ^_^

And then the story turns towards life after high school with short, but critical time slip after graduation. Again, if you haven’t been keeping up, you’ll get to see a much more masc-presenting Mitsuki who is working on her music with a band, and Aya who has committed to a career in translation. Joe makes a huge decision for himself, as well. 

In many ways the second half of this volume is a wholly new story, about two young adults building their new adult lives and their relationship. Old friends are still part of those lives, but new people are joining the cast as well. 

I’m going to re-read this volume at least once more in Japanese and will be looking forward to it when Yen puts it out in English. There’s no release date at time of writing, but I’m hoping for it in early summer. 

Ratings:

Art – 8
Story – 9
Characters  – 9
Service – There’s a valid argument about the prom outfits as service. But as for salaciousness, 0
Yuri – 10

Overall – 9

Up until this volume, there has been almost no conflict of any kind in Arai Sumiko’s school and music Yuri series. In Kininatteru Hito Ga Otoko Janakatta, Volume 3, (気になってる人が男じゃなかった), we are now meant to take this story seriously enough that there are several situations that pass for conflict.

But first! A music festival. Aya, Mitsuki, Narita, Jo and Kanna all got to Fuji Rock, and have camping/festival fun and trauma. If you have ever done a massively large camping/event all of this will be so familiar to you that you, like I, smiled – and grimaced – with renewed memories. It rains. I remember that.

The music festival is the catalyst for everything else in this volume. Mitsuki, enamored of the acts on stage fantasizes about joining them. Aya is of course egging her on, as she too loves to see Mitsuki on stage. This precipitates several crises. I will avoid spoilers here, as this is the plot, but the crises are, simply, Mitsuki shedding her “school” persona for her truer self which then reverbs into a crisis for Aya who is 10000% Mitsuki’s fan and friend and also disproportionately jealous about Mitsuki in a way that causes her to create distance between then in order to preserve their “friend”ship over the “relation”ship they were building.  This all builds up to a very funny scene, in which Narita narrates “Narita Geographic.” I laughed out loud at that.

The other crisis is…the prom. Narita comes across the school principal crying at a movie that culminates in a romantic prom scene. In one of those moments where the series chooses to 86 reality for plot sake, Narita encourages the idea of prom at their school and the principal, says, “Great, you handle it.” Thus, a prom will happen. There will be yet another conflict, exacerbated by all the previous conflicts. If you are concerned at the outcome, I suggest you follow Arai-sensei on one of her several socials. The spoiler is worth it. I amend that to, the spoilers are always worth it. ^_^

I have mentioned several times that my wife and I do not like the same things much of the time. Even when we like a thing, it is often for different reasons. In the case of The Guy She Was Interested In Wasn’t A Guy At All, she reads Volume 1, then Volume 2, then starts again and is impatiently waiting for Volume 3. I, on the other hand, am impatiently waiting for Kininatteru Hito Ga Otoko Janakatta, Volume 4. YES, I know what happens. I want the whole book anyway.  We must both wait as Volume 2 in English and Volume 3 in Japanese are recent releases, but we can foot tap if we want. ^_^

Ratings:

Art – 8
Story – 9
Characters – 9
Service – 3  Mitsuki being cool is still this series’ service
Yuri – 7

Overall – 9

As I pointed out upon returning from New York City, knowing that mid-town Kinokuniya is fully decked out in green advertising for this series is nice, but actually *seeing* how much expensive retail space this series is taking up, is something else. Like, a whole order up of “holy crow.” Kino, Kadokawa and Yen are advertising this series in a way I have never, ever, seen for a Yuri story. As the series in question is lovely and sweet and charming and fun, it feels extra wonderful. No “yay for Yuri, but ugh, what a shitty series.” We can offer this our full-throated, full-hearted support…and we can get merch! By buying a copy of this volume at Kino, I now have an adorable standee and a rubber bracelet “signed” by Mitsuki, as well as a wonderful volume of a delightful Yuri manga. ^_^