Archive for the Yuri Manga Category


Yuri Manga: Himitsu no Recipe, Volume 2 (ひみつのレシピ)

October 15th, 2013

In Volume 1 of Morinaga Milk’s Himitsu no Recipe (ひみつのレシピ), we met Wakatsuki and the President of the Cooking Club, on whom she has a raging crush. The feelings appear to be almost entirely one-sided, however and, as we head into Volume 2, Wakatsuki’s delusion about the two of them is clearly headed for a fall.

The problem is two-fold. One, the previous president of the club has taken to returning from time to time and it is quite obvious that the current president has deep admiration for her sempai. Wakatsuki sees the older woman as a rival.

More importantly, Wakatsuki is not a member of the cooking club because she enjoys cooking or wants to learn to do it. In fact, she’s a hot mess in the kitchen  and manages to sabotage nearly every meal with stereotypical “bad cook” tropes such as replacing sugar with salt. Sigh.

There are other only moderately funny scenes on top of this, culminating in the cooking club reluctantly eating crickets for a meal.

But Valentine’s Day saves the story, as Buchou offers to help Wakatsuki make chocolate and they exchange feelings and sweets. As the book closes, Wakatsuki tells the club in the most transparent way that her lover’s identity is a secret. I imagine no one was fooled.

As I said in my review of the first volume, this is not Morinaga-sensei’s strongest work. It’s not terrible, but there’s no self-awareness, no honesty, no real connection between the two. And as I worked on my lecture for Kanagawa U., I realized that that’s what I’m looking for in my Yuri – honesty.

Ratings:

Art – 8
Story – 4
Characters – 5
Yuri – 6
Service – 5

Overall – 5

It won’t kill you to read this, but I’m glad Seven Seas went with Gakuen Polizi for their next Morinaga title instead.





Yuri Manga: Tsuki to Doro (月と泥)

October 4th, 2013

When I reviewed Ohkita Hiroko’s Hadashi no Chimera, I was distressed at the overall damage, both physical and emotional, inflicted upon the characters. It comes as no surprise, therefore, that I was ambivalent about picking up her next book,  Tsuki to Doro (月と泥). While I would hardly consider this book perfect, it is much less bad in that regard.

Unfortunately – or perhaps fortunately – the title story follows the pattern of the previous book, with a wounded girl, and unlikely relationship and a murder. After that story, the tone shifts. Yes, there’s still a lot of physical and emotional damage, but more of the characters take control of their lives on their own and for their own reasons – reasons which may or may not become clear during the stories.

I enjoyed this book much more than the previous one, but I think Ohkita could do even better. A little more storytelling and a little less torture would go a long way.

Ratings:

Art – 6
Story – Variable, from 4-6
Characters – 6
Yuri – 6
Service – 4

Overall – 6





Yuri Manga: Comic Yuri Hime (コミック百合姫) September 2013

September 30th, 2013

The cover of the September 2013 issue of Comic Yuri Hime (コミック百合姫) is 3D, with a pair of glasses inside the magazine, so you too can look down the bikini tops of the girls of Yuru Yuri in 3D.

For me, one of the highlights of the issue was a fractured fairy tale by Minamoto Hisanari about “evil” stepmother Mars-sama, her step-daughter Snow, and the magic mirror, that was utterly silly and not all that sweet, really.

Momono Moto’s “Kuryaami no Asterisk” finishes up with both characters stepping out of their bad habits and reaching out to one another. A better ending than beginning.

“Bousoku Girlsteki Mourou Reainaiteki Suteki Project” heats up with a bitter rivalry for Student Council Vice-President. Less “harem battle” than I expected, but still kind of fun.

Takahashi Mako’s “Mujintou e Matte Ikunara” was lovely. Honestly the best story I’ve ever read by her. The feeling of going through life alone, as if one was on a deserted island, is something that probably many readers of manga can identify with.

I absolutely loved Katakura Ako’s “Warawane Majou no Shikeisenkoku” in which a witche’s prediction comes true, with a smile.

Nana is still working through her feelings for Satomi, but once she learns Satomi’s not-so-secret secret, she comes to a conclusion of a sort in “Kiss ChuChu” by Takemiya Jin.

The circumstances change between Ruki and Sachi, but not necessarily for the better, in “Watashi no Sekai o Kousei Suru Chiri no You na Nanika.”

Zaou Taishi and Eiki Eiki’s “Love Gene Double X” is climbing tortuously towards a climax. We learn the source of the bitter feelings between Sakura’s and Aoi’s families as they face each other in a duel. The loser will be forced to become an Eve.  I’m still super uncomfortable at the direction of this story and I don’t have any hope that the real issues in the story will be resolved. Grrr…

In “Rock It Girl” by Tanaka Minoru, the band faces a new crisis/opportunity as they head to a summer music festival. Kaede is moved so deeply by the energy and the crowd that when Seira kisses her, she doesn’t resist. For a moment the two of them are able to not freak out and just be comfortable together.

The 4-koma strips “Nekoyama-san to Inugami-san” and “Kimono Nadesico” go through the paces as they usually do. Fans of “Yuri Yuri” and “Yuri Danshi” will find nice juicy bits to enjoy.

Ratings:

Overall – 8

This was a pretty decent volume.





Yuri Manga: Kimi no Tame Nara Shineru, Volume 3 (姫のためなら死ねる)

September 22nd, 2013

51K9VwUbD2L._SL500_AA300_Before I begin today’s review, I would like to take a moment to thank every one of you who purchased and read ALC translations on JManga. It was such a pleasure to be able to bring you all fun Yuri manga in a digital environment. Of all the books we worked on, the hands-down most difficult was Kuzushiro’s Kimi no Tamenara Shineru (姫のためなら死ねる). Erin S. did amazing work translating it, and both of us ended up doing quite a bit of research for it. It was a challenge and a pleasure. Thanks to Erin  and thank you all for your support. I’m sorry we’re not going to have the opportunity to bring you Volume 3, but I’m pleased to be able to review it, at least. ^_^

As established in Volume 1 (reviewed here in 2011) and Volume 2 of this series, famous Heian period diarist Sei Shonagon is a slacker, blogger and…crazy.  If we take a moment to think about life in the Heian Imperial Court without any idealism , we can guess that it would have pretty much been life at any dorm anywhere – politics, backstabbing, crushes, affairs and pranks. This is exactly what we see in this manga.

Speaking of pranks, we are introduced to Ichijou Tennou,  the Emperor to whom Teishi and Shoushi are Consort. In reality, Ichijou’s reign is emblematic of the Heian period at its finest, with an Emperor who loved and encouraged art and literature. In this comic, he is 12 years old and as tsundere as possible.

The rest of the volume plays out as usual. Shonagon swings back and forth between ecstasy and misery as she is the focus of Teishi’s attention. When Teishi’s mother suggests her daughter use her wiles to control the distance between her and her lady in waiting, we almost get to see Shonagon proclaim the title oath all the way through, until she is interrupted.

Yuri is, as it always is in a gag series, is a mixed bag of misunderstanding, silly set-ups and other things that make people pant and get red in the face, like illness and sports. Which brings me to Kemari, which is the hackeysack-like, non-competitive sport played as early in Japan as 644 CE.  One of the funniest set of gags in the manga is Shonagon, who has no idea how to play, teaching Teishi, who also has no idea what she’s doing.

As a goofball look at Heian court life, Kimi no Tamenara Shineru remains a highly amusing manga that is totally worth the effort it takes to read.  ^_^

Ratings:

Art – 6
Story – 8
Characters – 8
Yuri – 4
Service – 4 (And a weird 4, too. Having a cold is really not that sexy.)

Overall – 8

I admit, I hope that life in the Heian Kyo looked more like this, than Tale of Genji.





Yuri Manga: Omoi no Kakera, Volume 2 (想いの欠片)

September 13th, 2013

One of the three titles I chose for 2011’s Top Yuri Manga was Omoi no Kakera, Volume 1 by Takemiya Jin.  Specifically, I very much enjoyed our introduction to Mika, a confident, self-aware young lesbian.

In Omoi no Kakera, Volume 2, Mika’s relationship with underclassman Mayu develops significantly. Where in Volume 1, Mayu begins with distaste that develops into a crush, in Volume 2, Mayu starts to genuinely care about Mika…and Mika learns that she’s developed some affection for the younger girl. After the coffee house owner lays it out to Mika, that her insistence that she prefers older women is merely a way of clinging to her past, Mika tells Mayu the whole story of her first love. Mayu’s reaction is very sweet. And for the first time, I have some confidence that they could, possibly, become a healthy couple, maybe. Just as they reach this place, it appears that Mika’s past has indeed caught up with her.

The main story has a few Intermissions. Under “not really a couple and, so, not unhealthy, but wtf?” comes the coffee shop owner and her roommate. I have no idea what the deal is with them. ^_^;

The Intermissions include a short, really cute story about Mayu’s brother (who we know from the early chapters of Volume 1, is gay) and his crush, a male classmate.

The book also contains a short story called “Love & Piece,” which has a rough start in some hideous stereotypes and a really bad set of choices, but ends in a good place.

I have saved the best/worst story for last.

As Mayu has manages to get closer to Mika, her best friend Saki has taken a lot of hits over the years. When Mayu expressed disgust for gays, Saki was unable to admit that she was a lesbian. But when Mayu needed her, she was always there. Now Mayu is falling for Mika, and Saki’s lonelier than she ever thought possible. Saki’s story is heartbreaking, but very well told. I can only hope that Volume 3 brings her some happiness.

I love this story. It is full of the hormonal, irrational, high/lows of teenage life, and full of gay kids who are still finding themselves. Mika, Harada-kun and Saki are not alone, but we all have to reinvent the wheel for ourselves to some extent.

Ratings:

Art – 9
Story – 10
Characters – 10
Yuri – 9 / Lesbian – 9
Service – 4 for “Love & Piece”

Overall – 10

Takemiya-sensei tells a damn good story.