My Idol Sits the Next Desk Over! Volume 1

January 28th, 2022

Sakiko is a shy, introverted person. Unsure of herself, she never knows what to say. But secretly, she has a passion – she is obsessed with a pop idol singer, Chihiro, part of a upcoming group Spring Shine. When Sakiko sits down in her seat, she is shocked to find Chihiro sits right next to her! What she doesn’t know is that the creepy, stalkerish fan that haunts all of the Spring Shine boards is *also* in her classroom. Welcome to My Idols Sits the Next Desk Over, Volume 1.

I’m going to be honest here…this book starts out rough. The stalker, Maya, is obnoxious and toxic, bullying an already nervous Sakiko. Chihiro is friendly, but a bit clueless. About halfway through, I was starting to feel as if this book was going in a direction that was deeply uncomfortable to be understood as a comedy. But, then, surprisingly Sakiko makes a move. She includes stalker Maya in her just-forming relationship with Chihiro…and the three of them become, tentatively, a unit.

And that simple turn takes this whole series from zero to hero. In a later chapter, Sakiko decides to join photography club in order to, of course, take pictures of Spring Shine. Her new sempai takes amazing pictures, but disdains pictures of humans. So, Saikiko drags him along to a Spring Shine concert where he finds inspiration!

The art is typical, with a lot of scared, pained, anxious faces at the front end, and a lot of genuine delight towards the end.

If this is the tone this manga is going with, Sakiko becoming the person she can bem  I think I can be convinced to come back for more. The first chapter’s Sakiko was too nervous and victimizable, I suppose is what I’m trying to say, to be likeable. But once she takes the situation into her own hands, the whole story becomes palatable and, dare I say it, enjoyable.

Ratings:

Art – 7
Story – Starts at 6, but moves up to 7 by the end
Characters – 7
Service – Not really
Yuri – Is one-sided obsession Yuri? The jury is out on this.

Overall – 7

Would I recommend this? Sure, if you’re looking for a quick read that doesn’t ask too much of you… sure. 

Final note: Spring Shine is a great idol group name. ^_^

2 Responses

Leave a Reply