My Next Life as a Villainess Side Story: Girls Patch is something we get very few of in the west – a series-focused manga anthology. And, in this case, it’s even rarer – a Yuri doujinshi collection for a not-really-Yuri series, which makes it that much more of a throwback to the kinds of anthologies I used to spend a lot of time on. ^_^

The series in this case is My Next Life as a Villainess, the goofy, light-hearted harem isekai about Katarina Claes who, on account of a minor head injury as a child becomes suddenly aware that she is a character in a game – in fact, she is the game’s villainess, with a very bad end awaiting her. In Katarina’s attempts to avoid her fate, she befriends all the main player characters, including the game’s protagonist. 

Katarina’s friends are more than just besties, as her sincerity and kindness has made them all fall in love with her. Girls Patch is a collection that focuses on the female characters., Lady Mary, Sophia and in-story game protag Maria, and their desire to be as close as possible to Katarina. 

Like the originating My Next Life as a Villainess Light Novels, the stories in this collection are cute, sweet, only every so slightly risqué, with a strong emphasis on Katarina’s clueless charm. Also like the originating novels, the art is simplistic. Nothing deviates from the scenarios set by the novel series. Which makes Girls Patch a relaxing interlude, but offers little substance. This is a series for folks who love the characters as they are written and want to see more of them, not folks who would like to see a little deviation from the script. In other words, this is another Ichijinsha anthology, where creativity takes a back seat to the scenario as written.

That said, if you love the fact that Sophie, Mary and Maria are in love with a clueless Katarina – if that vibe is your jam – then you will enjoy this book. It is indubitably cute AND sweet AND touching and ever so slightly Yuri.

Ratings:

Art – 7
Story – Not really, but that’s not why you’re reading
Character – 100 THIS is why you are reading
Service – 3, maybe 4, depending on your feelings about Katarina’s face on Mary’s chest
Yuri – The feelings are there, but that’s all we can hope for…let’s call it a 5

Overall – 7

When series anthologies were the best and often only way we got more time with the characters, artists felt freer to explore the relationships outside the scripted versions. Love affairs were (and still are) among the most popular topics of doujinshi stories, in which fan artists and writers capture the characters we don’t see in the original text. This current crop of company-created doujinshi collections aren’t willing to do that, which always leaves me feeling….but, why bother, then?

If you love the series as written, you will love this collection. If you were hoping that this was going to be the Yuri stories you wanted for Katarina and her female harem…this is not that.