Archive for the English Manga Category


Whisper Me A Love Song, Volume 7 and Volume 8

May 7th, 2024

Shiho has what we used to call a “difficult” personality. She appears to make decisions that work against her best interests more often than not. Should you happen to point it out to her, you become the problem. In Whisper Me A Love Song,  Volume 7 and Volume 8, Himari finally helps Shiho to see that the problem is that Shiho has piled every one of her issues up to form a barrier between her and Aki…and, really, she likes Aki, it’s just that all that stuff has kept her from admitting it. With the high tension of the school festival filling the air, will Shiho break permanently with her former bandmate, or open a new chapter between them?

When we learn, finally, what Shiho’s issue is – it is a perfect moment. Yes, of course, his would affect her and yes, of course, someone as high-strung and “difficult” as she iswould retreat into herself, finding fault with everyone around her, rather than taking a look at herself. But Shiho also comes off as selfish and willful here. When the penny finally drops and she sees what she is doing, it is very satisfying. We (and Himari) are immediately hopeful that Shiho will figure out how to build a healthier relationship with Aki.

In the mean time, back in mostly-functional relationship land, Himari and Yori enjoy their first school festival together with all the little joys and moritifcations that brings.

And then the Battle of the Bands begin and Lauraley comes out swinging. Who will win is not nearly as important as what will happen after that, but our little angel, Himari has shepherded her sempai into a situation that is much more likely to be win-win. Good on her.

These volumes are perfect high school drama. Just a teeny little bit of real world drama, and a lot of adorable love-love, unencumbered by concerns of growing up in a hostile world, centering on good friends, and having fun playing music. It’s the perfect recipe for fulfilling high school years.

Thanks to the team at Kodansha for doing a top-notch job with the character voices, so that when we hear them speaking in the anime – streaming now on HIDIVE – they really sound exactly the way we imagined they would. ^_^

Ratings:

Art – 9
Story – 8
Characters – 9
Service – 0
Yuri – 8

Overall – 9

 





Kase-san and Yamada. Volume 3

April 29th, 2024

Two young women, a tall one  one with short brown hair and a shorter one with collar length pale hair, dressed in white berets and red coats, surrounded by images of pastel christmas tree balls College life has become a little more normalized for both Kase-san and Yamada. Yamada’s got a job, and loves her classes. Kase-san is still struggling with her unregulated emotions about Yamada, and with her so focused on Yamada, she’s not really noticing what’s going on in her her own dorm room, where Kase-san’s roommate, Fukami, is going through some stuff on her own.

When the school festivals collide, Kase-san finds herself making bad choices – again – but this time it’s Yamada who stands up and talks Kase-san down. And it’s Yamada who asks Kase-san to move in together. It’s pretty clear that Kase-san’s imagination is still a problem, but Yamada…she’s grown. And in doing so, she’s going to help Kase-san do so as well.

It’s so interesting that we still have this manga, more than a decade after it began. As a result, we’re still watching Kase-san and Yamada mature in slower-than-real time. As a result, this manga retains the sweet, slow style we became familiar with originally and we’re just that much happier when these two find a moment of special joy.

Now we just need Kase-san to get over that issue with jealousy. She’s about to feel what it’s like on the other side of that equation.

Ratings:

Art – 8
Story – 7
Characters – 8, Yamada is a 9
Service – 0
Yuri – 8

Overall – 8

As always, the team at Seven Seas has done a bang-up join in bringing over a manga that I am still amazed continues! I kind of want to see them both graduate and move into the adult world together…and still keep growing together.





I Can’t Say No to the Lonely Girl, Volume 1

April 26th, 2024

A girl in a black blazer and gray school skirt with long dark hair look over with trepidation as a girl with collar-length pink-brown hair, cups her cheek and leans over her shoulder, the string of her tie in her teeth.

Ayaka is an excellent student, who has a hard time taking tests. In return for a recommendation from her teacher to any college she chooses, she finds herself responsible for bringing a truant classmate back to school. She doesn’t really know Honda, but how hard can that be? Well, when Honda demands a quid pro quo in the form of a “favor”- and the first favor turns out to be a kiss – it’s a bit complicated.

My memory of this series in Comic Yuri Hime was “This was a sweet series, I’m glad it was licensed.” But, I had completely forgotten that the premise is kinda trashy, kinda funny. That said, as we see even in this volume, the story moves away from that fairly quickly.

Almost immediately Ayaka can see that something is up with Honda and a few questions turn up a lonely family life. So Ayaka invites Honda into her circle of friends, on the supposition that if she is having fun at school, she’ll want to keep coming. This decision is what changes the tenor of the story from one of uncomfortable skinship to one of friendship.

Ratings:

Art – 8 This is conjecture, but Kashikaze’s art is so familiar, I think they must have been someone’s assistant.
Story – Errrrm…not a great start, let’s say 6
Characters – 7 with room to grow
Service – 5 It’s light as fanservice goes but non-consensual kissing is still salacious and not really cute, IMHO
Yuri – 5 De facto, but more emotional depth to come

Overall – 7

They original premise will pop up again from time to time, much like the teacher from the bushes, but Kashikaze’s story will – I promise you – develop into something worth reading.

Volume 2 is headed our way very soon, in English from Kodansha, with more stolen kisses, but also more of everything else.





Assorted Entanglements, Volume 3

April 10th, 2024

A woman in pink hair and headphones sits in front of a keyboard, in a gaming chair, while a woman with blue hair leans on the desk next to her.by Matt Marcus, Staff Writer

Previously in Assorted Entanglements Volume 2, sparks and virtual bullets flew as we met mangaka Heke-sensei and her editor Shinohara, who not-so-anonymously play an online First Person Shooter game together while harboring mutual crushes. Meanwhile, Shizuku and Shiori slowly float closer to each other, somehow.

For Assorted Entanglements Volume 3, Mikanuji-sensei must’ve thought “hmmm the last new couple was a little too wholesome. It’s time to spin the Wheel! Of! Problematic! ‘Ships!” A giant prize wheel rolls in and is vigorously spun. Plasticky ratcheting sounds burst out then slowly decelerate as the selection arrow slowly passes over OL x JK, then Sister x Sister (Adopted), and finally Sister x Sister (Not Adopted) before landing on: Teacher x Student. A sizzle reel plays for the winning couple. For some reason they are riding jet skis at a Sandals Resort.

That’s probably not how it happened (I’m sure there was an editor involved somewhere). However, it is less dire than you may be thinking. For now.

Our new pair of star-crossed acquaintances is the stoic gym teacher Kujou and one of her students, 3rd year Sugimoto. Every day after school, Kujou stands outside the door of a lesbian bar, too afraid to enter. Inevitably, she chickens out and instead frequents the maid café next door where Sugimoto works. Sugimoto, who is a bit of a misanthropic loner despite her good looks, decides seemingly on a whim that she is going to help Kujou on her quest to enter the bar and finally find herself a girlfriend.

It becomes clear pretty quickly that Sugimoto is on her way to catching feelings for Kujou; blessedly, her gym teacher doesn’t even register her as an option, despite noticing that her student is pushing the boundaries of a proper teacher/student relationship. (I hate that I find this refreshing.) Regardless, the comedic dynamic between these two works. Sugimoto’s acerbic tongue is a fun foil to Kujou’s sad puppy vibes. I’m just mildly concerned about where the story is going to take them.

Aside from these two, there are still three other “couples” to check in on. Not too much has changed between Minami and Iori, however the same can’t be said for their “jilted” hangers-on. In fact, Shizuku’s hard-assery has softened considerably towards Shiori, much to the latter’s chagrin. You can see the little dance they are doing, inching towards each other then repelling apart mostly because Shiori likes to throw Shizuku’s feelings back in her face to goad her into anger for a laugh. Despite that, progress is being made. For some reason, I’m rooting for them.

Meanwhile, Heke-sensei and Shinohara begin spending more and more time with each other, often pretending to be lovers for “material” to inspire Heke-sensei’s storyboarding. Each time Heke-sensei tries to close the gap, Shinohara’s bluntness and desire to hide her crush ends up unintentionally sending the wrong signals to her coworker/secret gaming buddy. They are the goofiest and most wholesome pairing in this series, so it’s always a nice reprieve when they show up.

I mentioned the art’s Same Face Syndrome in my review of Volume 2, but somehow the issue has now spread to entire characters. You can’t have your characters say a line like “you should be able to recognize your students” and then give multiple characters 99% the same face and haircut.

These are three different characters. Two of them are 12 years apart in age. No, I can’t tell them apart either.

Also, every now and then there’s some weird body proportions. There’s one panel in particular where Shinohara’s right arm appears to have grown 30% too big for her body.

The thing that continues to hold my interest is the humor (again, shoutout to Eleanor Ruth Summers for the excellent localization). Unfortunately, there are still moments of “yikes” that keep me from truly singing its praises. It’s like eating that PB&J sandwich you packed with you to the beach: no matter how careful you are, you will get a bite or two of sand that feels like it’ll crack your teeth. In one notable case, Minami is acting passive-aggressively and Iori has no idea why, and it turns out that she is grumpy because the night before, Iori, who was blackout drunk, did something out of pocket in bed. It’s supposed to be a reversal joke, but there’s enough “ick” to it that it is hard to handwave, let alone laugh at it. The series continues to be one that has enough rough spots to make it difficult to recommend.

But despite my complaints…I am still reading it. This is perhaps the funniest volume so far, and there’s plenty of joy to be had in cropping out panels as reaction images or meme fodder. You just have to be OK taking your Yuri with a grain of sand.

Art – 6 Seems like the art has regressed a touch, and the sameness of the character designs is not helping
Story – 7 A handful of questionable choices hurt it, but the humor stays sharp
Characters – 7 This really is a manga for people who like Women/Girls Who Suck
Service – 4 Iori and Minami’s sex life is still present, and it is a little uncomfy in a couple places
Yuri – 9 / LGBTQ – 9 You did hear me say lesbian bar, ya?

Overall – 7 I’d tell it to run a few extra laps

Volume 4 is currently available in English from Yen Press, with Volume 5 arriving in June. A twisted Yuri comedy with some punch.

Matt Marcus is a serial enthusiast whose range of appreciations include guitars, watches, and a particular genre of Japanese popular media named after a flower. Outside of writing for Okazu, he cohosts various projects on the Pitch Drop Podcast Network, where he frequently bloviates about video games, anime, and manga. He also hosts a blog Oh My God, They Were Bandmates analyzing How Do We Relationship in greater depth.





A Sheep Princess in Wolf’s Clothing, Volume 2

March 29th, 2024

A wolf girl in a dress decorated with black trim, and a sheep girl in a flowery frock embrace in an ethereal bedroom setting.by Luce, Staff Writer

In Volume 1, we met Aki, a Wolfa butler, and Momo, a Sheepa princess who announced her intent to enter a relationship with Aki. They went on a date with Momo in disguise. Here, in Volume 2 of A Sheep Princess in Wolf’s Clothing, we see the end of that date, where the queen’s friend, a dressmaker, gets Momo to try on a load of outfits that reveal a fair amount of skin, leaving Aki pretty flustered. They also prepare for an event to celebrate Momo’s coming of age, wherein Aki is reminded that Momo will likely have to marry someone soon… and that won’t be her. Just how does she feel about Momo anyway?

The idea of either marrying into royalty or being long lost royalty had been a trope in fiction for centuries. The escapist ideal of being a lost princess, or being the (usually) woman to get to marry a handsome prince, is the older fantasy version of today’s ‘if I win the lottery’. It’s understandable – for the vast majority of people both then and now, royalty and wealth was something far out of reach and only attainable through fiction. You could argue that wish fulfillment is one of the oldest reasons to make stories.

This is sort of one of those. Aki is a commoner, albeit a servant in the royal castle, which must be a relatively high up position, while Momo is the princess that fell in love with her. In real life, this would be a horrendous power imbalance. In fiction, Momo barely acts like a princess, her maid ships them, and it’s clear they’ll get together by the end of the manga, so the politics is just a complication between their happiness, rather than anything to get too bogged down in.

The thing that amuses me is that the fact that Aki is Wolfa and Momo is Sheepa is made very little of. The royal family is Sheepa, and they are in the land of Sheepa, but many of the commoners are Sheepa, too, and while the influence of the moon on Wolfa is noted and commented on several times, this isn’t seen as a problem, just a consideration. If you like girls with animal ears, you have plenty of them here – the mangaka states here that the story started from a one shot, so we get the author ‘wish fulfillment’ here; it’s not stated, but I suspect they just wanted to draw cute girls with animal ears and made the story around that.

This volume actually introduced other ‘races’, although most are in the background, except a hyena character (Hyenaa? It’s not mentioned) Kunya, a princess from another country, who looks similar to Momo’s first love, the reason she shut herself away in the first place. We also get a glimpse of a troubled part love of Aki’s, although no details. Perhaps in a future volume.

I’m not in love with the fact that the first love of Momo’s is darker skinned and clearly not a great character, nor that the Hyena princess, Kunya, feels like she’s set up to be a third member in a love triangle – but at least she seems to be nicer than the other character of colour we see. I’m hoping that Kunya isn’t just a plot device.

Art – 9
Story – 6
Yuri – 8 (I mean, there really aren’t even many men given page time, there are two budding lesbian relationships and previous ones)
Service – 8 (Momo tries on some slightly scandalous clothes, and has a bath. It doesn’t feel super salacious, but it’s there.)
Overall – 7

If you liked the first one, there’s plenty more here to keep your attention. I’ll be continuing to read – hopefully Kunya will get a bit more development, I enjoyed her character.

Luce is collector of books, part time reader, identifies as a book dragon. I can be found on Discord as farfetched1235. I also have a Goodreads as Luce where I do mini reviews on the manga and graphic novels I read, and a Storygraph as farfetched where I do the same with novels and light novels. I hope you enjoy this review today!