Archive for the Matt Marcus Category


Botan Kamiina Fully Blossoms When Drunk Anime, Episodes 1-5

May 17th, 2026

The title art for Botan Kamiina Fully Blossoms When Drunk. On the left is the title logo, while on the right is a collage of the main characters. One girl has long straight purple hair, wearing a white button front shirt and a slight smile. Below her, a strawberry blong girl with long wavy hair leans chin on hand, looking longingly to the side. Next to her is a girl with pink hair tied up in a pony tail with a black ribbon, tuning a red Yamaha Pacifica guitar. One girl has a wheat-colored bob and is holding a bottle of alcohol, leaning over a railing in the boarding house. One girl in a black knitted sweater dress and sporting medium-short black hair sees herself in a mirrored fireplace mantle, on which there is an assortment of airplane-sized bottles of alcohol. In the foreground of all of these is a girl with long pink hair tied up in dual ponytails with blue ribbons. She is wearing a light blue overcoat over a midnight blue cocktail dress. She's holding a giftwrapped bottle of booze and is sporting a slight smileIn Botan Kamiina Fully Blossoms When Drunk (currently streaming on Crunchyroll), incoming (hic) college freshman, catches her RA Tonami Ibuki enjoying a whiskey highball at a spring festival. Ibuki, who is something of an alcohol otaku, only drinks alone because…she hiccups a lot when she drinks and has a complex about it. Botan is charmed by her (hic) regardless, and the two end up as drinking buddies, and perhaps something more…?

It turns out Botan, who took a convenient gap year so that she’s of legal drinking age (burp) as a freshman, turns into a big flirt after a drink or two–no surprise, given the title of the show. Thankfully, she’s not the handsy type, but there’s an odd purity to the dynamics here. I’m not asking for sloppy drunken makeouts in a pile of empty Yebisu cans…OK I kinda am, I remember what it was like in college. (hic) Really, Botan just got the big ol’ doki-dokis for Ibuki, and her RA is just a bit too overwhelmed by her forthrightness. But also, the show does twist itself into knots around Ibuki’s hiccup hangups. It is (hic) mildly annoying to me as a viewer when you know the show is going to find a way for every other character to leave a scene just so Ibuki can be alone with Botan and feel comfortable drinking. (hic)

Three other girls round out our small cast: the quick-tempered Yaeka Kitamori, her travel-partner-cum-possible-musician-girlfriend (?) Akane Yusa, and Kanade Gujou, the cigarette-smoking (hic) grad student with a failgirl crush on Ibuki. As of this writing, there is a sixth cast member who has yet to arrive, I assume to pick Gujou up out the smoking wreckage that she made for herself trying to get Ibuki to (hic) notice her. They are all perfectly fine, though they are all fairly one note so far.

Here’s the thing with this (burp) anime: not a lot happens. The girls in various permutations find themselves traveling, drinking, or often both. Some light flirtation occurs, maybe some mild yearning or angst. End scene. A character-driven story this is not; I know more about series creator HEY’s taste in music from one scene in episode 4 than I do about any of these (hic) girls. But there sure is a lot of product placement, mostly of alcohol (note that the anime had its own sake collab), but also Yamaha music equipment.

The Botan Kamiina anime is a spiritual successor to the Bocchi the Rock adaptation. My evidence:

-pink-haired protag ✅
-yuri/yuri-ish elements ✅
-animation showcase ✅
-Yamaha guitar product placement ✅

— Matt Marcus (@hyperartmarcussan.bsky.social) May 2, 2026 at 9:52 AM

If you are expecting fireworks, you will find it in the animation flexing that inexplicably shows up in (nearly) every episode. Much ado (hic) has been made online about the intentional changes in art style and direction between each episode, with different staff leading the production week to week. Mostly I find this successful, but occasionally it can be VERY distracting (looking at you, Episode 3). If nothing else, it covers for the otherwise (burp) languid development of anything you’d call plot. I will say though that the OP, with a song performed by yonige and made to look like handheld Super 8 footage, is gorgeous, as are the watercolor-styled ED sequences that do a strong job fleshing out each character’s backstory. There is a lot of craft being put into this anime, but the substance of the story itself is (hic) fairly thin.

It really is hard to pin down this (hic) show. It’s not hobby enough to teach you about brewing or mixology; it’s not travelogue enough to be a guide book (although people have already made their own); it’s not quite Yuri enough to do more than whet the palate for something more. For me, personally (burp), I don’t want to just see Botan sip delicate sakes or infuse upper-shelf single malts. I want to see her wax poetic about the top notes of Mad Dog 20/20. I want to see her do Edward 40-hands with Steel Reserve. I want to see her drink like a college student, damnit! (hic) Also where do they get the money for all of this.

If it sounds like I’m damning with faint praise, fear not. I’m enjoying watching this series every Friday night, with a drink (or two) in hand, as you might have been able to tell. (hic) Bottom’s up, y’all.

Art – 7 Knocking off a point for ep 3
Story – 5
Characters – 7
Service – 3 Bartending is service, right?
Yuri – 5

Overall – 7

Botan Kamiina is currently streaming on Crunchyroll on Fridays.

One thing to note: there was a recent blow-up on social media around HEY’s bookmarked art on Pixiv, particularly at least one that included Botan in a (seemingly) non-yuri scenario. Whether or not that crosses a boundary of good taste or morality is something that everyone should decide on for yourself. Having looked into it myself, I am personally less bothered by the fanart and more troubled by some other choices, but nevertheless I will continue to follow the series.

Matt Marcus is a cohost of various projects on the Pitch Drop Podcast Network. You can find him mostly reskeeting Yuri posts and sports takes on Bluesky @hyperartmarcussan.bsky.social





#Gal x Gal Yuri, Chapters 1-11.2 on VIZ Manga

February 4th, 2026

Five gal/gyaru-style high school girls pose together in front of a blackboard. From the left is a blonde-haired girl with red highlights wearing a pony tail, a blonde girl in a bob cut with purple highlights, a long-haired brunette with tan skin winking while showing a peace sign, a blonde long-haired girl, and a the tallest, a silly-looking girl with a very long black hime-cutby Matt Marcus, Staff Writer

Have you ever thought to yourself, “Why search for a new lover when I could be dating my bestie instead?” Well, do I have a yuri for you!

#Gal x Gal Yuri is exactly what it says on the tin. Blonde bubbly Yua and the cool tan beauty Reina are high school comrades in cosmetics who decide to spend a year dating each other, and I quote verbatim, “for the vibes.” We see them go on dates, celebrate birthdays and holidays, become the spring festival mascots of their class (and run a maid café, natch), and finish their year-long experiment very much still in love.

And that’s chapter 1.

My instinct is that the first chapter was a one-shot doujinshi that was repurposed for the serialization, but it’s funny how much gets jammed in there before things slow way down for the remaining ten chapters of the volume.

The dynamic between the leads is simple but fun. Yua is so enthusiastic to the point where she is constantly gushing or gloating about her affection for Reina, in a way that disarms anyone who might have looked sideways at an openly queer relationship (notably, they encounter no trouble with anyone on that front). Reina, on the other hand, plays the “straight man” role mostly by rolling with or occasionally reining in Yua’s flights of fancy. But really, this is a comedy series and the jokes do mostly land. Occasionally Yua’s talk about sex makes me want to take a spray bottle to her, but I can’t say it seems out of character for a teenager.

There are other supporting cast members—a pair of twins Akane and Shion, and Yua’s childhood friend Yazawa (a “rocker” chick who is somehow the most head-empty of the cast)—to help round things out. Yazawa takes up most of the air when she is present, but for the most part this is the Yua and Reina show.

Inoue’s art helps carry this series. It’s cute without being too cutesy; the fashion is, of course, well represented; and I find the reoccurring off-brand Instagram posts charming. The one thing I would say I don’t have a firm perspective on is Reina’s skin tone and what it could or could not signify; my bet is that it’s simply an aesthetic choice.

If you like gals being more than pals, this one is worth smashing that follow button for.

Ratings: 

Art – 8 Appealing, reasonably detailed, used well to emphasize gags
Story – 7 Not a lot of plot but enjoyable nonetheless
Characters – 7 Characters are shallow but very charming
Service – 4 One panel of a bath scene, plenty of sexual jokes, lots of gyaru fanservice
Yuri – 9 Plenty of yuri “for the vibes”

Overall – 8 highly decorated nails out of 10

While the first tankobon is available in Japan, the current 11 chapters (plus two bonus stories) are currently only available in English on the VIZ app and website.

Matt Marcus is a cohost of various projects on the Pitch Drop Podcast Network. You can find him mostly reskeeting Yuri posts and sports takes on Bluesky @hyperartmarcussan.bsky.social





Otakon 2025 Field Report – Rock Is A Lady’s Modesty Panel

August 17th, 2025

Photo of Miyuri Shimabukuro, Shinya Watada, and Hidetake Nishigaya posing in front of the crowd from the second RockLady panel at Otakon 2025. Shimabukuro-san and Watada-san are holding chibi dolls of the main cast.by Matt Marcus, Staff Writer

The familiar barrage of guitar notes of “Ready to Rock”, BAND-MAID’s opening song for Rock Is a Lady’s Modesty, hyped up an expectant crowd. On stage, however, was not the band; present instead was RockLady’s Director, Shinya Watada, Otoha Kurogane’s voice actor, Miyuri Shimabukuro, and Producer Hidetake Nishigaya. The topic at hand: the staff’s favorite scenes and a peek behind the curtain on production.

The Saturday morning panel was the group’s second during this year’s Otakon, the first being held the day before in one of the larger conference rooms of the Walter E. Washington Convention Center. Having only the chance to visit the conference on Saturday, I was curious whether interest in the series was strong enough to carry a second session. I was pleasantly surprised; despite the smaller room, the attendees, roughly 120 in total, were as loud and raucous as a Fuji Rock crowd (or at least my imagination of such). I was pretty impressed by the number of fans who showed up to hear more about a niche title that aired on a small streaming platform.

The panel was MC’d by Nishigaya-san, with Watada-san and Shimabukuro-san as the guests of honor. Both shared two clips each that were their personal favorites and discussed why. Watada-san highlighted two post-jam ending scenes; Otoha’s first colorful outburst and immediate switch back to lady-like speech from the end of episode 1, and the battle of the bands scene with our full group panting, sweating, in front of a stunned crowd. Both moments were stressful to direct, and he was relieved that they managed to hit with the intended impact.

Shimabukuro-san’s choices were both spirited character moments. First was lead character/guitarist Lilisa and Otoha’s first exchange of vulgarities in episode 3. The second was Lilisa’s defense of the rock greenhorn Tina in episode 8. She would mention that her biggest challenge was keeping her speech intelligible during the not-infrequent torrents of screamed insults.

After the favorite scenes section, the panel moved on to Q&A. Shimabukuro-san mentioned taking drum lessons to get into the role, but given her novice status she did not end up drenched in sweat like her character. The staff were asked about their favorite Western rock bands (Watada: Bon Jovi; Nishigaya: Green Day).

The most interesting revelations came towards the end. Nishigaya-san touted one last surprise: a prerecorded segment with BAND-MAID, who provided both music and motion-capture for the musical performance scenes. Of their anecdotes, my favorite was from drummer Akane Hirose, who said that Otoha’s freestyle drumming in episode 1 was an unrehearsed jam that was requested at the end of a recording session. 

All in all, it was a fun panel. The only mildly disappointing part was that Akira Sekine, the seiyuu for Lilisa, was not there to trade stories with Shimabukuro-san, which could’ve brought out some more lively banter. Also, there was no season 2 tease or even a shoutout to the upcoming localization of the manga coming next month. Still, I was pleased to see that the show garnered enough love for there to be two panels dedicated to it.

After the panel I left the hall and grabbed myself a chili-smothered half-smoke at the Ben’s Chili Bowl stall located at the north end of the convention center’s skybridge that spans across L Street. Given the central location, I had a great vantage point to watch the throngs of anime fans passing by, many in cosplay. While I didn’t see anyone dressed up as Otoha or Lilisa, there was still plenty of RockLady-like rebellion put on display. Perhaps the next time I make it to a convention I will see more proper ladies saying “Gokigenyou~” with middle fingers up.

Rock Is A Lady’s Modesty is available for streaming on HIDIVE, and volume 1 of the manga will be coming out in English via Yen Press on September 23rd.

Matt Marcus is a cohost of various projects on the Pitch Drop Podcast Network, as well as the writer for the blog Oh My God, They Were Bandmates analyzing How Do We Relationship in greater depth.





Bad Girl Anime, streaming on HIDIVE

July 30th, 2025

Six high girls in school girl outfits in various poses. A multi-colored logo said “Bad Girl.”

by Matt Marcus, Staff Writer

Your butt is mine, gon’ tell ya right

So opens Michael Jackson’s 1987 mega-hit “Bad”. I’ve always found this line risible, like a 7-year-old trying to sound cool. Don’t get me wrong, the song is a certified banger, but no amount of buckles or hip-thrusts were going to convince me that MJ knew how to throw down.

Even less convincing is Yuu Yuutani, the titular so-called Bad Girl,streaming on HIDIVE. You see, she wears earrings (that are actually paper clips)! And she doodles on the bus window! That will definitely catch the attention of her beloved senpai and public morals committee member, Atori Mizutori, won’t it? Turns out she’s very bad and being…well, bad. But despite this, she gets her wish, as Atori finds herself fascinated with this small scared animal who follows her around.

Every character is an easily identifiable archetype: we have the socially inept lead; the grumpy gyaru best friend with a crush; the conceited clout-seeking cutesy girl; and the well-admired and respected senpai. Not much in the way of surprises here, although aside from the “school idol” girl they are likeable enough.

Nothing about Atori’s sudden interest in Yuu makes a lick of sense aside from the fact that there wouldn’t be a premise without it. You can’t look at Bad Girl and expect anything resembling verisimilitude or character growth—it’s simply a vehicle to deliver well-worn jokes around our lead struggling to communicate yet failing upwards. There is also a layer of lewdness to the gags that feel very calculated, starting with the OP that includes several moments of our cast posing with each other in the nude for no reason.

The animation is solid, the comedic timing is tight and punchy. It’s a well-executed version of what it is: a gag manga adaptation with few fresh ideas. To paraphrase Wesley Snipes: it ain’t bad.

Art – Cutesy. Very cutesy
Story – Goofy and fluffy
Characters – Here just to be silly
Service – Kya-hoo out of 10
Yuri – Should’ve called this series Down Bad Girl

Overall – It’s not bad, but it’s not particularly great either

You can watch this series on HIDIVE, if you’re bad enough

Matt Marcus is a cohost of various projects on the Pitch Drop Podcast Network, as well as the writer for the blog Oh My God, They Were Bandmates analyzing How Do We Relationship in greater depth.





SHWD: The Complete Yuri Collection

July 21st, 2025

by Matt Marcus, Staff WriterTwo women line on the ground smiling at each other. They are both wearing SWAT-like outfits that are covered in black gore. One woman has red hair, a fit build, and a mechanical arm. The other has short black hair and a broad build

CWs: death, gore, child murder, attempted suicide

If these reviews had bylines, this one’s would be “the perils of world building”.

In SHWD: The Complete Yuri Collection, major cities are plagued by the Dynamis, a bio weapon made during the previous world war. Those exposed become immediately violent and attack all of those near them. Airi Koga, a bulky, muscular 22-year-old woman is the newest recruit at the Special Hazardous Waste Department, a private company that specializes in the neutralization of Dynamis.

Koga gets paired up with the Tokyo division’s ace Shino Sawada, a steely woman who seems purpose-built to fight the Dynamis. Koga is immediately smitten with her new boss, and spends the duration of the story wagging her tail at any scrap of approval from Sawada.

In general, I like the dynamic between the leads but I didn’t find it strong enough to bear the weight of the whole series. The problem ends up being that neither character changes very much over the 16 chapters. Koga pushes through every red flag and warning given to her about Sawada, but she is too ensorcelled to acknowledge them. The emotional climax of their story is simply Koga asserting that her puppy-love for Sawada is real in defiance of a big reveal that should otherwise cast extreme doubt on Sawada’s character. It also doesn’t help that this climax lands in the middle of a messy exposition dump that feels like set up for a longer series that we will never see (more on that later). Nevertheless, if you love Yuri where the leads show their affection through their fists, you’ll likely be plenty pleased with their arc.

There is also a secondary pairing from the Fukuoka branch: Leone “Leo” Cass and Nonaka. The former is a hunky, affectionate operative from the US; the latter a short-tempered ex-yakuza. I felt this pairing had the strongest thematic resonance: Leo lost her 8-year-old daughter and has become viscerally nauseous at the sight of children, while Nonaka lost family members and school friends to an attack that left her body unable to mature, forever stuck in the form of a child.

Leo is by far my favorite character in the series: she adds both levity and pathos, both with her playful-but-caring nature and her vulnerability. Despite appearing in control at all times, she has an emotional weak point that, when exposed, sends her immediately into deep despair. It really highlights how the Dynamis’ mental pollution leaves even the strongest operatives balancing their sanity on a knife’s edge. Nonaka, unfortunately, is as half-baked in her characterization as she is in her physical appearance. Despite her, dare I say, shitty demeanor towards Leo, there is “dere” under that “tsun”, but we are never told whence that affection came which leaves her feeling a bit hollow. That said, the way that Nonaka offers herself as Leo’s safe space to recover from mental pollution feels surprisingly sweet. However, it comes with the obvious caveat that while Nonaka is mentally mature, the optics of her and Leo together has some notable ick factor.

One of the draws of a sci-fi setting is the ability to explore themes with extreme precision. SHWD has a clear setup to explore how people process and react to grief. Every named operative was motivated to join the company because of someone they lost to the effects of the Dynamis—and we are shown enough of those gruesome moments to give bite to the characters’ feelings. The problem is that the story doesn’t follow through with this angle, and instead shoehorns in a conspiracy plot in the final stretch that ends up undermining those motivations. As it turns out, SHWD is secretly the causers of the Dynamis outbreak (due to an unnamed disgruntled evil scientist, natch). Leo drops one line about staying with SHWD simply to minimize harm, but it. It’s the equivalent of someone joining an addiction center run by Perdue Pharma after a loved one died of an opioid overdose.

Sawada stands ominously in front of closed blinds in her office, telling Koga in the foreground "This is the world's plot."

When she ’bout to tell you the world’s plot.

What also doesn’t help the final narrative twist is the way it is written. The pages where Sawada explains the Dynamis’ true history is, to be frank, very incoherent. The grammar and sentence structure doesn’t flow at all, or at best does if you squint really hard. One section reads:

“As world wars became more frequent, the weapons needed to end them became increasingly more radical.

In other words, soldiers lost their fighting spirit.

A weapon that affects the spirit of enemy soldiers is difficult to reproduce.”

I think the meaning here is supposed to be something along the lines of: “Constant world wars with escalating weaponry began to seriously erode the morale of the military rank-and-file. With their existences on the line, many governments developed methods to combat the emotional tolls of war, but their effects were short-lived.” What’s on the page feels like a very rough-cut translation that took me multiple reads to parse.

I don’t want to make any firm claims, but given that Seven Seas decided to forgo separate volume releases after the first one and instead pivoted to an omnibus format coupled with the fact that this wasn’t a problem anywhere prior to the Volume 3 sections makes me wonder if shortcuts were used for the later chapters. It could also be plausible that it’s just as confusing in the original Japanese. Either way, you can tell that sono.N was wrestling with fitting in “the world’s plot” in the limited space of the back of this series. It’s as if the world-building was too good for the space that was given, leaving me wanting the themes and character motivations to be more consistent and clear than they are.

I would say that I do like sono.N’s art. The Dynamis are formless but very creepy, the character designs are fun (props again to body diversity), and the action is well-conveyed. Occasionally, though, characters do look off model in a way that messes with their scale relative to each other: case in point, Koga looks a lot less beefy on the cover compared to inside the book. It’s a minor gripe, though.

If you are looking for a short Yuri sci-fi story with badass women in it, and you can stomach some bad things happening (mostly to children), this meaty omnibus is an easy book to recommend. I just know that a lot of meat was left on the bone. 

Art – 8 Plenty creepy when needed
Story – 6 A lot of potential that was left unfulfilled and a bit grim at times
Characters – 7 Koga and Leo are plenty loveable, the rest…eh
Service – 4 Mostly if you like muscular women (plus one bath scene)
Yuri – 8 / LGBTQ – 8 The imprint is called “Girls’ Love” for a reason

Overall – 7 A snack that could have been a four course meal

Matt Marcus is a cohost of various projects on the Pitch Drop Podcast Network, as well as the writer for the blog Oh My God, They Were Bandmates analyzing How Do We Relationship in greater depth.