Archive for the Guest Review Category


Hyakko Complete TV Series Anime, Disk 2 (English) Guest Review by Matt W.

September 25th, 2013

HyakkoCTS

A few weeks ago, I reviewed Disk 1 of this series and at the time, I gave away a copy of the complete set, thanks to TRSI. The winner had to write a review of Disk 2. And so, with great pleasure and appreciation, I welcome brand new Guest Reviewer Matt W. to Okazu on this Guest Review Wednesday. ^_^

Hello there, I am Matt W.

Based on a 4-koma gag manga, like most school slice of life shows these days have as their basis. Hyakko is the adventures in the life of four high school girls (Ayumi, Suzume, Tatsuki and Torako) and a school with a bunch of rather eccentric students. It’s like a slightly wacky version of Azumanga Daioh.

Disc 2 is about all about introducing more side characters and developing the main girl quartet.

Episode 5: Torako gains a love interest/hopeless romantic Shishimaru. It also introduces the Photo Club: Koma-chan the girl in Torako’s class and her boss Yanagi who is a rather obsessive photographer and gains a rival/buddy in the punk girl Ushio as they spend a lively afternoon together.

Episode 6: Tatsuki is dealing with being left out one day but then surprise Torako, Ayumi and Suzume show up at her house one afternoon. We also get a look into her home life involving her absentee parents and therefore her need for a live-in house maid Toshiko.

Episode 7: We are introduced to Kitsune-san, a sly fellow (as his name suggests) who starts to hang out with the Photo Club. Later he is revealed to be Torako’s aniki (big brother); he’s also a skirt flipper which leads to a slight bump of fanservice certainly.

Episode 8: Proper introduction of the scary girl/Sadako lookalike Inori; easily shunned and avoided by her classmates; Torako tries to get Inori to open up and be friendly; ‘hair-ality’ ensues.

Focus goes towards other characters, so they grow and the show’s story can develop in interesting directions, exploring them beyond the school setting. Though most of the humor amounts to “School Shenanigans”, but since this is slice of life series that isn’t a bad thing. The plot seems a bit more grounded on this set of four episodes, but the characters and their interactions are still very zany and funny. There isn’t so much a story, but a string of interconnected vignettes again tying it back to its 4-koma origins. Nene Andou is the main draw for potential yuri still in this series, although her appearances are more sparse then in the first four episodes. Granted, one can discern some form of yuri subtext when wearing the ‘yuri googles’ to be sure. This disc also contains an extended preview (between episodes 6 and 7) made after the series aired on TV which is only mildly entertaining and yet superfluous at best. I also like how the episode portions are marked by which manga chapter they are based on, as if to say ‘hey remember this?’ to the part of the audience that read the manga. Of course, this doesn’t mean much as the manga has yet to be licensed much less released over in the USA.

Bits of Beethoven music used during the scenes of Shishimaru and Torako interacting which was comically effective I must say. In addition, Liner notes on the DVD are very nice addition as they help to explain some of the more esoteric details/references in the show.

Ratings:

Art-6
Story-4
Characters-6
Yuri-2
Service-6

Overall-6

Far from being a laugh out loud show, like Azumanga Daioh or NichijouHyakko is certainly chuckle-worthy at the best of times.The thing to keep in mind about slice of life anime is that they are gimmick-based: for example, K-On! has music, Kiniro Mosaic has foreigner humor/cultural misunderstandings, etc. Hyakko‘s gimmick lies in pure eccentricity and the nice thing about it is that the show nearly revels in being eccentric and totally wacky without an ounce of shame or regret.

On a final note, I shall plug my own blog for anime reviews: http://eclecticdudesanimereviews.blogspot.com/ as well as an article I wrote for Animation Revelation, another anime/animation review website (a 3 Reasons article on Bodacious Space Pirates).

E: Thank you Matt, for your perspective! We’ll be getting a third opinion for Disk 3. ^_^





Vividred Operation Anime (English) Guest Review by Jennifer L.

September 4th, 2013

vividred

Welcome to another exciting Guest Review Wednesday! Today’s special treat is a review by Jennifer L. Once more I say this, with feeling, Okazu readers are the best. You make this blog better in a million ways. Thanks to Jenny and thank you all for reading. ^_^

Aniplex USA recently launched a new partnership with Hulu (subject to region limitations, of course), which has led to numerous new anime series being released through that streaming service. One of these is Vividred Operation, a magical girl / sentai anime with heavily-implied Yuri elements. The series centers around second year junior high school student Akane Isshiki, a papergirl with a flying bicycle, a little sister who acts as the adult in their family, and a mad scientist grandfather. In the first episode, we learn that the grandfather, Kenjiro Isshiki, developed a zero-point energy reactor known as the “Manifest Engine,” which now supplies 95% of the world’s energy needs.

All is not sunny, however, because seven years ago, the reactor (built on an artificial island off the coast of Tokyo which clearly owes design inspiration to Shimizu’s “green float” paper study) overloaded, killing Akane’s father, and seriously wounding her mother, who is still in the hospital throughout the series. The incident admitted an extradimensional alien force, the “Alone,” to the world. The powers that be, however, refused to believe in the Alone, and blamed Dr. Isshiki for the incident. Isshiki, we learn, has been preparing ever since then to fight the Alone when they inevitably return to try and destroy the Manifest Engine again… which they do in the first episode. How has he been preparing? By creating “pallet suits” keyed to his granddaughter Akane, which run on the “Vivid System” to make her (and eventually, her friends) into superheroines, of course!

There is plenty to dislike in this series. The characters are relatively two-dimensional, with the initial emotional problems they have quickly erased by the power of friendship. Fan-service abounds: virtually every shot in which we look past a character is a butt /crotch shot… many of them lined up so that we’re looking between a character’s thighs at whatever she’s looking at. There’s at least one Magical Girl transformation in each episode, which features lingerie-clad early-teen girls looking awfully happy to be getting suited up in their pallet suits. In addition, however, there’s a secondary transformation which occurs, in which two of the girls “dock,” combining into a single, more powerful version which has large, bare, bouncing breasts as she gets suited up.

There’s also a lot of “but never mind that,” going on. The alone came through seven years ago, but waited for our heroines to get old enough to fight them before they attacked? Well, never mind that. Dr. Isshiki is in disgrace and making no money, so his granddaughter has to work multiple part-time jobs to support the family, but somehow the mad genius has the money to create the pallet suits? Well, never mind that. Dr. Isshiki’s work on the pallet suits comes to fruition in an explosion which “somehow” transfers his conciousness into a stuffed animal? Well, never mind that. Dr. Isshiki, now in a stuffed-animal body, can somehow move, talk, and needs to eat and drink? Well, never mind that.

In spite of these drawbacks, I find myself very much enjoying the series. Interestingly, other than Dr. Isshiki himself, males essentially don’t exist within the series. They appear on screen from time to time, have a line or two, and then disappear, never to be seen again. This series is all about the Girl Power. The executive director of the Manifest Engine is a woman; her secretary / assistant is a woman. The Japanese Defense Forces pilot who becomes the heroine’s contact with the Establishment is a woman. And, of course, the heroines and the anti-hero are all junior high school girls.

There are strongly implied Yuri elements. When the Mad Doctor tells Akane and her best friend Aoi that they can / have to “dock” to become stronger to fight the Alone, and that the docking is accomplished with a kiss, Akane is puckered up and ready to go… with Aoi being initially hesitant, but then falling into the plan when Akane talks about how Aoi’s friendship makes her “tingly all over.” The two friends embrace in their underwear, and become one.
There is some interesting word play going on with the character names. Akane means “madder” in Japanese, and madder is a root used to create red dye. Aoi, her best friend, has blue eyes and blue hair, and Aoi of course means “blue.” The third girl to get a pallet suit, Wakaba, has a name meaning “young leaf,” and as you might guess, is the green member of the team. Fourth comes Himawari, “sunflower,” who becomes the yellow heroine. Each of these girls in turn “docks” with Akane to become an older, more powerful version of herself to defeat an Alone. Later in the series, Wakaba and Himawari develop a secondary intense relationship between themselves as well.

The series hits all the tropes of the Magical Girl series, almost as if checking them off on a list. I can’t decide if it’s deconstruction, pastiche, or just laziness on the part of the creators, but if you like that kind of thing, this is just the kind of thing you like.

Art – 7
Story – 3
Characters – 3
Yuri – 3
Service – 9

Overall – 5

Bottom line on this series: I’m enjoying watching it, but if Final Fantasy XIV wasn’t constantly overloaded to the point I can’t log on, I probably wouldn’t have watched the whole thing.

Jennifer Linsky is a nurse in North Carolina. More of her writing can be found on Jenny’s Blog Thing of Doom.

E here: Fantastic review, Jenny! Thank so much. To your point about it seeming like they used a checklist…you’re not imagining it. There are a number of fandoms that really, actually do checklist. (If the tsundere character isn’t twin-tails and a rehead, the series is no good. Or if the series doesn’t have a dashing blond, a brooding dark-haired guy and shota character, it’s no good.) They do it so they hit most of the main fetishes of the intended audience, of course.

One last note: the series is also streaming on Crunchyroll, and will be ad-free if you have an account.. Thank you again!





A Certain Scientific Railgun S Anime (English) Guest Review by Mara

August 7th, 2013

ACSRSWoo-hoo! It’s Guest Review Wednesday! Please welcome back serial Guest Reviewer Mara!

A Certain Scientific Railgun S (streaming for free, legally with applicable region limitations from Funimation) is a direct sequel to the anime A Certain Scientific Railgun… which doesn’t have ‘S’ at the end. Picking right up where its predecessor left off, it adapts the manga of the same name. If you are one of the lucky ones who only watched the anime of either Railgun or its mother series A Certain Magical Index, you should give this new season a go right now as it will be more of the same – i.e. an incredibly entertaining esper action story.

However if you are as voracious a consumer of the ‘A Certain Blank’ franchise as myself, you may be hesitant. Understandably so as this new series of Railgun is forced by existing cannon to now tackle the story arc that pushed Railgun into the so called ‘dark side’ of Railgun’s setting: Academy City. A story that focused on illegal cloning and perhaps the most gruesome form of level grinding in fiction. Known as the “Sisters” story arc – in the original novels it was responsible for introducing a lot of important characters; such as Kuroko, the Misaka clones and Accelerator. When it came time for the Sisters arc to appear in the Railgun manga the story focused almost entirely on Mikoto’s point of view leaving fan favourite characters out of the spotlight for an extended period of time; pretty much assuming you had already seen the Index version of the story in some way.

Not so for the anime adaptation. The anime gives you a complete story to enjoy and while Mikoto and the Sisters arc cast take centre stage we are not allowed to forget the rest of the cast, including characters that were introduced in the first Railgun anime:

By that I mean that Haruue is still around as is Banri, both characters from the first season. It is a treat to see that the anime staff did not just ignore them and assume that no-one would care if these characters appeared or not. In a show that had less effort put into it Haruue would have been put off stage now she has been reunited with Banri, instead we see their story continue alongside everyone else’s.

But it is Kuroko Shirai who receives a good portion of episode seven all to herself with her own sub-story that includes Saten, Uiharu and Haruue too. It keeps Mikoto’s story from becoming the dense all-encompassing mass it was in the manga buy piding up other events that would otherwise be entirely sequential. It also gives us an important glimpse of Kuroko’s view of Mikoto during this period, how concerned she is and the frustration that comes with trying to help someone who does not wish to be helped.

New to the Railgun story are quite a few scenes from Touma’s point of view as a digest version of the events he experienced in Index to add context for those who may have not seen or not remember the Index anime (way back in 2009). The manga assumes that we have seen Touma’s point of view before and thus gives us little to explain his appearance or motivation.  The anime however does show us how Touma finds out about Mikoto’s situation, including his interaction with Kuroko which involves a fun bit of perv to perv verbal combat that I really enjoy.

So if you have read the manga like myself and are wondering if you should bother with the first half of Railgun S, rest assured. The first season improved and expanded upon the story and the second season does the same with its source material far better than expected.

Score so far (Episodes 1-16):

Art – 7
Character – 10 (The A Certain Blank series is a fantastic example of Erica’s thesis that every character should have a unique ‘voice’. You would not mistake one character for another based on their lines… apart from the clones.)
Story – 6
Yuri – 5
Service – 9
Overall – 9

E here: Well, you’ve convinced me to watch it! I was dithering, since the manga had been so gloomy, but okay, I’ll give it  a try. ^_^ Thanks so much for the review and the prompt to reenter Academy City once again. ^_^





YuriTetsu ~ Shiritsu Yurigasaki Joshikou Tetsudobu Manga (ゆりてつ~私立百合ヶ咲女子高鉄道部) – Guest Review by Bruce P

June 19th, 2013

“Once upon a time there were three little sisters,” the Dormouse began in a great hurry; “and their names were Elsie, Lacie, and Tillie; and they lived at the bottom of a well—”‘

This Alice in Wonderland line effectively describes the manga YuriTetsu ~ Shiritsu Yurigasaki Joshikou Tetsudobu (ゆりてつ~私立百合ヶ咲女子高鉄道部) Volume 1, by Matsuyama Seiji. The story involves three little girls (though not sisters) who live at the bottom of a well. They are the Yuritetsu—the Yurigasaki Girl’s High School Railway Club. They recruit a fourth little girl to their club, and go on train trips. But the whole time they never leave their well. Which is to say they travel all around Japan without ever interacting with or even seeing another person, except for one old guy in one panel on one page. Not another living soul in 191 more pages. There are occasionally dim outlines of other people, but these are drawn as indistinct phantoms. Their isolation is truly bizarre. It’s almost as bizarre, though not quite so head-banging, as seeing high school girls drawn as four-year-olds. And these are just two of the many short circuits in Yuritetsu.

The author isn’t inept, he just knows his audience. This isn’t a manga for folks looking to read a good story; that crowd will be somewhere off in the approximately real world reading Aoi Hana, or maybe Asagao to Kase-san. This is a manga for fanboys who like girls, without knowing too much about them, and who like trains, and who pretty much live in wells of their own. Logical consistency can be a major annoyance when all you really want is to see drawings of four-year-old high school girls in swimsuits. And trains. For some, of course, even the trains get in the way.

The story goes like this—Elsie, Lacie, and Tillie, three typical character types (tsundere; food-obsessed wack; quiet computer geek) are the members of the Yuritetsu. They meet Peanut, a new student at Yurigasaki High, and convince her to join the club. Peanut, the girl whose odd pose in the cover illustration suggests she’s just finished reading the manga, is the usual character type that stars in these kinds of quartets, the clueless klutz. Idiocy, so endearing. The girls take trains. They eat ekiben. They go to the beach. They never attend school. The end.

It’s not much of a story, but the story isn’t the point. Yuritetsu is really a travelogue of railway lines in Japan with little girls as your guides and as your companions (isolated as they are from the rest of the world, you don’t even have to share them with anyone). You ride to Hokkaido and stand in the snow; you explore the newly reconstructed Tokyo Station; in a chapter titled “Tetsu-on!” you ride the train to Toyosato and visit the high school where K-ON! was set. And so on. And at the end there are the swimsuit scenes. Ewww. It’s a bubbling stew of fanboy fetishes. It’s probably selling nicely.

So is there Yuri, as vaguely implied by the title?

Oh come on, these high school girls are four freaking years old. But for wellish fanboys the Yuri couldn’t be more obvious. Elsie, Lacie, and Tillie fall hard for Peanut, and who can blame them, she’s such a stammering, wide-eyed dope. So before you know it, they are fighting to stand next to her. They stand next to her a lot. They can’t get enough. And it’s not just two of them at a time – sometimes three, and occasionally all four girls will brazenly defy the conventions of 21st century morality and stand together in, as the French would say, though they would say it atmospherically in French, a group. Who knew it was that kind of manga?

Ratings:

Art—5. Well, the train illustrations are pretty good.
Story—2. Not so much.
Characters – 2. Elsie, Lacie, and Tillie are actually named Mamiko, Maron, and Hakutsuru; Peanut is Hatsune. For the record.
Yuri—2. All girls, so it has to be there, right?
Service—10. The reason it exists.

Overall—3. Of all the short circuits in logic contained in this volume, the oddest may be that this manga could actually be used as a little reference guidebook when visiting different railways, as it includes handy maps and information. The disconnect is that in reality, this would mean opening it up in public, and… ewww.

Scary fact #1 about this manga: there are two more volumes.

Scary fact #2 about this manga: the author has another series involving trains and girls titled Tetsuko na Sanshimai that is creepier than Yuritetsu.

Erica says: Happy Guest Review Wednesday, thanks Bruce and hahahahahah!





Yuri Game: Heileen 3 – Sea Maidens, Guest Review by C. Banana

April 5th, 2013

heileen headerToday we have a special treat. Long-time commenter C. Banana has joined the Borg taken up the pen and become an Okazu Guest Reviewer! How excited am I? Very, I assure you. As you know, I do not game, so I am thrilled to be able to let C. tell us all about a Yuri game. Take it away C!

I’m here to talk about an indie dating sim/visual novel in the form of Heileen 3: Sea Maidens from Winter Wolves. For those who don’t know, Sea Maidens is the standalone expansion to the otome game Heileen 3: New Horizons offering four potential Yuri romances. It does help to play the first two Heileen games but it’s not necessary as the third game explains enough that newcomers won’t be lost. If you’re considering buying the first two games, keep in mind that some Yuri fans may not like them, as they’re more Yuri-lite than the third game expansion gets. That said, if you own an Android tablet, Heileen 1 & 2 can be found cheaper on Google Play.

The setting for the Heileen series is during colonial times on an expedition to the New World. The game series puts the player in the shoes of the titular Heileen, a very young noblewoman, who starts out the series very spoiled and immature -although she does get better over time. The events of the first two games involve the initial expedition crashing, resulting in Heileen and friends being stranded on a tropical island. At the end of the second game, Heileen is rescued by relatively friendly pirates which starts off the events of the current game.

Before delving into the romance part, the simulation part of the game should be get a comment. Basically, you train Heileen’s stats and skills to possibly get a possible non-romantic profession ending for Heileen. Usually in simulation games, the first part of the fun comes from the discovery of all the mechanics. The next part of the fun comes from using knowledge of the mechanics to figure out the puzzle of how to use them to achieve your goals. Unfortunately, the simulation side of Heileen 3 is way too simple to find any of this kind of enjoyment from the game and it doesn’t affect the romance scenes at all, anyway.  It’s lucky for the game that the simulation and profession bits are not the main draw – but it does seem like a missed opportunity as it could have added to the game’s enjoyment.

As for the romances, they’re set up in the usual visual novel way, where the choices you make direct who Heileen ends up with (if anyone at all).  For Sea Maidens, the romantic choices are a childhood commoner friend (Mary), a vivacious women in her early forties (Lora), an ex-slave African woman (Ebele), and an irascible pirate lady (Juliet).  As this game was built off the original otome game, the early parts of the game do involve Heileen heavily crushing on guys. If you  only own Sea Maidens, the guys become  impossible to romance.  All of the romances are reasonably long as each playthrough should last multiple hours unless a player is skipping text like crazy.

***

Subcribe with Patreon Enjoy today’s post? Subscribe to Okazu with Patreon!

***

As for my comments on the romance paths…

Heileen/Mary – One thing that really surprised me about this route is how high the drama was during this romance, especially for a childhood friend option.  Luckily though the drama didn’t overstay its welcome for me and I ended up enjoying this route quite a bit.  As someone who’s played the first Heileen, it was nice touch that there was quite a bit of contrast to the Mary route in the first game as Heileen shows herself as much more mature and competent during the third game’s Mary route.

Heileen/Lora – A confession I’ll make is that I liked the Heileen/Lora route in the first Heileen game.  That said, playing this route in Heileen 3 actually creeped me out a little as the mother/daughter vibe of their relationship is played up at the same time during this route.  I’m pretty sure people who can get past that would enjoy the route a lot more than I did.

Heileen/Ebele – This romance certainly plays out significantly nicer than the others as, during this route, conflict between Heileen and Ebele is kept to a minimum.  I liked this route in a mild way but unfortunately that doesn’t give me a lot to say about it.

Heileen/Juliet – I romanced Juliet the first time through and on subsequent playthroughs, I kept being tempted to play through her route again.  One really positive thing about this route is that both Heileen and Juliet go through a fair amount of character development during this route.  The ending CG is without a doubt my favourite of the bunch.  Also, in what universe is a kickass pirate lady not considered a plus?

heileen-juilet ending cg

 

All in all, the potential romances offered are different enough that most people should find one route that they particularly like.

Art – 7
Story – 8
Characters – 8
Yuri – 5 to 9
Service – 5

Overall – 8

Erica here. Thank you so much for this review and the lovely picture which we all can enjoy. ^_^ Sincerely, I can’t thank you enough. 

As always, if any of you, my dear readers, would like to offer a Guest Review, please take a look at these guidelines. I’m always on the lookout for points of view that are not my own and reviews of things I can’t or won’t review. Thanks again C. and here’s to more great Guest Reviews!