Ise-san and Shima-san Volume 1 (伊勢さんと志摩さん)

March 22nd, 2019

Something about Tokuwotsumu’s art really appeals to me. I have no idea what it is. Something about the way Tokuwotsumu creates characters also appeals to me, but this time I know exactly what it is. 

Ise-san and Shima-san, Volume 1 (伊勢さんと志摩さん) is not a Yuri manga. It is, however a delightful manga about two close friends and roommates who are very comfortable together and who challenge each other to live their best lives. It’s honestly a delightful manga about absolutely nothing.

We meet Ise-san and Shima-san, coworkers and roommates as they are contemplating their “Challenge” sheet, on which they decide upon things with which to challenge themselves. These include things like giving each other a surprise, or staying up all night. It’s a fun life and one without too much emotional strain. Ise-san and Shima-san actually quite like each other, and have a lot of fun together.

We learn how they didn’t quite have a chance to become friends in school, because they ran in completely different circles but, when Ise-san was assigned to break in the newbie at work and it turned out to be Shima-san, they’d been friends ever since.

What appeals to me about the characters is the lack of drama and the open friendship they have for one another. They support one another, confide in each other and just generally are very good friends without complication. It’s really nice and very rare to see friendships between women portrayed without drama in manga. As a result, this manga about two best friends is a perfect palate cleanser after yesterday’s review. ^_^;

 



Warui Onna no Ko Manga (わるいおんなのこ)

March 21st, 2019

When Kisaragi Mayu joins the Art Club in Warui Onna no Ko (わるいおんなのこ), everything goes to hell.

Mayu is, as the title says, an evil girl. Through manipulation, both sexual and emotional, physical torture and blackmail the entire club becomes her slaves or is injured and even killed for resisting. The pages of the volume close on the teacher for the art club showing obeisance to Mayu and being tattooed by Mayu’s slaves.

It’s a cheerful little manga, as you can imagine. ^_^

Crazy eyes and shock eyes inhabit most of the panels. The art is all the more disturbing because it is good. The story is disturbing because it is disturbing.

When I heard that Complex Age creator Sakuma Yui was drawing a Yuri manga, I had no idea what to expect. I expected a Yuri manga, at the very least. This story isn’t Yuri, so much as uses the frisson of Yuri as one of the various forms of predatory grooming and psychological manipulation. So…that was fun. (-_-);

Ratings:

Art – 8
Story – 4
Characters – 3 One has hope at the beginning. Not so at the end.
Service – 5 It could be worse, but there is a lot of blood
Yuri – 1

Overall – 4

Depending on what you like, but I found it dire. If you like trainwreck stories starring creepy assholes successfully being creepy, you’ll love it.



Yuri Manga: Beauty and the Beast Girl (English)

March 20th, 2019

Neji’s Beauty and the Beast Girl is, exactly as it sounds, a Yuri fairytale.

A blind girl named Lily Blind meets and falls in love with a beast girl who she names Heath. Let it never be said that fairytales aren’t symbolic. Heath hides from humans in the forest and spends most of her time loathing her own form until Lily brings her out of her shell.

What follows is a gentle tale of redemption and love and growth for both Lily and Heath. As this is a fairytale and a romance, we never have any reasonable expectation that Lily and Heath will be parted, but as all good fairytales have some conflict, this does have some potential for disasters that are, of course, averted by love.

Neji-sensei is clearly a fan of non-human x humans romance, as I am simultaneously reading Volume 2 of Prisontown e Youkoso! (my review of Volume 1 can be read here,) from Comic Yuri Hime, in which a human finds herself in a supernatural town where she lives alongside fanciful creatures from myths, fairtyales and legends.  So this particular pairing is spot on for this creator’s ouvre. ^_^ The story is sweet, with more attention paid to character design than plot, which also seems typical of Neji’s stories.

The ending of this comic is very doujinshi-esque, where it ends, rather than wraps up, but it is, after all a fairytale, so “and they lived happily ever after” is acceptable. ^_^

Ratings:

Art – 8
Story – 6
Characters – 6
Service – 3
Yuri – 8

Overall – 7

Commenting on Heath’s name, Lily says “I think there was another name for that flower” which, I am obliged to remind you is “Erica.” ^_^



Yuri Manga: Éclair Special Sukinano ha Onnonoko Kitao Taki Yuri Sakuhin Kessakusen (エクレアSpecial 好きなのは女の子 北尾タキ百合作品傑作選)

March 18th, 2019

It is always a special pleasure to be able to review a collection by an artist I have been following for many years. Today I will indulge in this pleasure once again by talking about Kitao Taki-sensei’s Éclair Special Sukinano ha Onnonoko Kitao Taki Yuri Sakuhin Kessakusen (エクレアSpecial 好きなのは女の子 北尾タキ百合作品傑作選) a collection from Kadokawa of 8 stories by a creator whose work has made me happy since the early 2000s.

Kitao-sensei’s stories are almost always centered around a pair of women, one of whom suffers from painful embarrassment and their lover who gently teases them because it’s so much fun. This collection also includes a few stories in which next morning jitters or poorly communicated feelings have a place in the plot but, everything generally works out.

Characters here are mostly adults, some workplace romance, some drunk sex, a few ill-considered choices, but there’s little melodrama.  There’s a lot of “this could be happily ever after, if that’s what they both want,” which works just fine for me. ^_^

The art is style that lays somewhere between loose sketchiness and tight drawing, but is neither one, nor the other. I’ve always like her style, but your mileage may vary on that, obviously.

My favorite stories in the collection are the bookmarks at the beginning and end, which follow Aki and Minami, an adorable couple, as we follow them in the morning and at night as Aki returns home from the office. Totally squee. ^_^

Ratings:

Art – 8
Stories – 8 Slice of adult life
Characters – 7 We don’t get much time with them, but they tend towards the emotional and adorable
Yuri – 9
Service – 4 There is some nudity

Overall – 8

This collection is a great opportunity to get a chance to see a less-known-than-she-ought-to-be veteran Yuri artist have free reign with her work.



Yuri Manga: Lillium Terarium (リリウム・テラリウム)

March 17th, 2019

Lilium Terarium (リリウム・テラリウム) by ED is a collection of short comics from Yuri Hime @ Pixiv. As YNN Corespondent CW helpfully noted, “The serialization was based on a 4 page piece which got quite heavily retweeted when it was posted on twitter.”

The book itself is impressive, with glossy pages, comics printed in one or two colors that differentiate arcs from one other and clear printed dust cover, Lilium Terrarium is more like an artbook than a manga.

The name is, frankly, perfect. We watch young women in a variety of typical shoujo-style Yuri set-ups, much as we watch snails in terrarium, with interest, rather than engagement. These are stories we’ve seen before, just the markings are different. That said, the book is a very nice version of that Yuri terrarium and the snails all have nice markings. ^_^

My favorite of the arcs is the Kanako & Yumi arc, which begins with four friends playing at the seaside. Kanako and Yumi’s relationship is comfortable, but the camaraderie between the four is what warmed the cockles of my heart. (I had a grandmother who used to say that. We used to make fun of her, but I think I just figured it out, the ventricles kind of looks like cochlae. HUH.) I also enjoyed the heavy dark lines of the Mei & Aki arc and loved that the book ended with a sweet lightly-colored and charming story about Nanayo and Juri, who adorn the back cover, as well.

As a reproduction of digital comics in paper form, it’s unique and quite lovely.

I picked this up at Shosen Book Tower so I got one of the special paper inclusions, this one of Mei, I believe.

Ratings:

Art – 8
Story – 7
Characters – 7
Service – 0
Yuri – 6

Overall – 7

All in all a nice, if not breathtaking, collection of Yuri schoolgirl stories which was more interesting for the presentation than the content.