Light Novel: R.O.D. Volume 3

February 12th, 2010

Meet Wendy Earhart. She’s working at the British Library, mostly because her Best Friend Forever Karen is, as well. Karen is working to pay the hospital bills for her mother who is in a coma. Karen is driven, focused and determined. Wendy’s just sort of there to be there. She likes working at the British Library, but she has no passion about it. She’s there to support Karen.

Until Wendy and Karen interview to work in the Special Weapons Section. They meet Joker, who asks them a question with no right answer: If you were on a boat with a famous author and his priceless manuscript and the boat went down, which would you save – the author or the book? Wendy says she would save the author, because people are more important than books and the author might create more great literature if he is alive. Karen says she’d save the book, because it is irreplaceable and who knows if the author would ever write something good again, but the book can be reproduced and bring joy to everyone. Joker tells them that they are both wrong.

Joker offers the job to both Karen and Wendy, but Karen turns it down. Wendy, who wants both the job and to support her friend, is roundly scolded by Karen who tells her to get her own life. Karen says goodbye to her ailing mother, cuts the life support, then leaves the Library for good, leaving Wendy to find her own way.

Wendy’s crisis starts when she tries to interrupt someone reading in the Library late at night and almost dies for her trouble. And so, Wendy Earhart meets Yomiko Readman, who ultimately tells her that she would save the book AND the man. But you can only save one, Wendy says, to which Yomiko replies, “That’s why I would save both!” Wendy goes back to the Library and accepts the new job.

Meanwhile teen author Sumiregawa Nenene is doing a book signing in Tokyo and she is not having any fun. And to make it all worse, Yomiko is late. In fact, she’s so late the book signing is over when she arrives. And she’s filthy and smelly. And someone is trying to kill Nenene.

Nenene and Yomiko, having defeated the bad guys, head out to Kyoto for the next book signing where Nenene is once again attacked – apparently her new book appears to have been plagiarized from the best seller by Clive Cussler. Cussler fans are not happy at all about this. But Yomiko – and the pelicans of Kyoto’s landmark tower – save Nenene once again. In a moving scene, Nenene asks Yomiko if her book does seem like she lifted the plot and Yomiko admits that not only does Nenene’s book seem like a ripoff of Cussler’s, Cussler’s was better overall. Nenene is very thankful for the honesty and realizes that she needs to grow and mature as a person in order to mature as a writer. She has a lot of fun at the next book signing as a result of her insight.

The final scene is why Yomiko was late. In short – she was stranded on a tropical island – with no books. It was a rather disturbing short with a bitter look at the difference between liking books and being an obsessive-compulsive bibliomaniac.

As with all the ROD novels, the beginning of Volume 3 was a little slow, the action was a little silly and Yomiko didn’t get to be quite cool enough to slake our thirst. But, the time she spends with Wendy and with Nenene she is so charming, that it’s easy enough to forget the bits where she’s freaking out for lack of something to read.

Ratings:

Art – 4
Story – 7
Characters – 7
Yuri – 2
Service – 2

Overall – 7

Nenene and Yomiko’s reunion and their subsequent heart-to-heart make everything worth it.



Yuri Manga: Yuri Hime Wildrose, Volume 4 (百合姫 Wildrose)

February 12th, 2010

It’s pretty evident that I’m not the average Yuri fan. I don’t read Yuri looking for titillation, I don’t particularly care if a story has sex in it or not. What I’m looking for is a good story.

Short stories are harder than long ones. You have less time to make a reader care about the characters, and less time to develop the situation. A lot of short stories that include sex scenes read like “Plot, What Plot?” stories – even if they aspire to be more than that.

Yuri Hime Wildrose, Volume 4 (百合姫 Wildrose) is a collection of PWP stories and frankly, it doesn’t aspire to much more. This is a collection for the Lowest Common Denominator who want sex in their Yuri and don’t really care much about story, character or plot.

The only stories that stood out to me were Nanzaki Iku’s attempt to *not* do another ShizNat-style story, Morishima Akiko’s story for being something I actually disliked from beginning to end and Takahashi Yostsu’s gang parody.

Nanzaki’s story shows us the relationship between a woman who works at a pet store and one of her customers. It’s sweet, a little dopey and has obligatory sex. It was a refreshing change from his usual. In balance I find myself starting to recognize patterns in the sex scenes he draws and that disturbs me a bit.

Morishima Akiko’s story is set in France, a girl who has to leave takes advantage of the girl she loves in a story that really put me off. It’s classic Cream Lemon, with a super whiny, yet willing to rape to get her way, protagonist. And it’s fake rape, you know, because the other girl wanted it, really. UGH

Takahashi Yotsu’s story was silly. Arisa is the leader of the Wildrose gang, but she falls in love with Serika, they hypercompetent employee at Ichinjinsha bookstore. When Arisa decides to leave gang life for Serika, she finds that her love is actually the Yuri Hime gang leader. Bwah wah wah~~

Other that these, the stories are a mix of unpopular/popular girls, and other blandly typical stories, with sex.

Ratings:

Art – Variable, but I don’t think it got better than a 7.
Stories – 4-6
Characters – 4-6
Yuri – 9
Service – 10

Overall – 5 for me, but more if you think Yuri equals girls having sex.

If having sex is your number one criteria for a Yuri anthology, then this is probably a book you will like. If you’re looking for something with a little character in the characters and oomph in the plot, give this one a miss. I was going to stop getting this series with this book, but Volume 5 is already looking intriguing, so I’ll give it one more try.



Light Novel: Taisho Yakyuu Musume, Volume 1 Guest Review by George R.

February 10th, 2010

It must be Wednesday. Oh, look at that, it is. Snow complicates everything, I’ve learned…even working from home. So thank heavens we have another Guest Review from George R to pick up the slack! The floor is yours, George! 

While over in Japan I picked up the first Taisho Yakyuu Musume novel. This is the original work which launched the manga and then anime series. I decided to take the bit in my teeth, the book in my hand and forge ahead without dictionary. This had the advantage of making it easier to read on the train (or station platform, like Fumi in Aoi Hana) but meant foregoing taking notes while I read. So this review will skip any detailed description of the novel in favor of comparisons with its two offspring. The first novel covers more time than the first manga, but less than the anime, only extending to the first practice baseball game.

While previously reading the manga I was curious whether it or the anime was closer to the original novels. It turns out that Itoh-sensei stayed much closer to the novel than the anime producers, and I think he was the perfect choice to draw the manga. I wondered about aluminum bats and the spring-based resistance training harnesses: both of these come straight from the novel, and are part of Noe’s strategy to beat the boys. Tomoe also helps with some innovative training ideas from her martial-arts background.

The novel delivers in one area that attracted me to this series, a good Taisho era feel. In fact at the end, we’re even given a small bibliography of books about the era. The Taisho era (1912-1926) was one of continued change and growth for Japan. Starting from an almost medieval level at the start of the preceding Meiji era, Japan built herself to be recognized as one of the 5 great world powers by 1919. Both politically and culturally the era saw a rise of the liberal movement. It also saw the beginning of long slow road of the woman’s rights movement in Japan.

The novel capitalizes on several trends of these times. The introduction of baseball is an obvious one, but the very middle school the girls attend is also emblematic. The mere 52 of these in Japan in 1900 had grown to 576 by 1924, the time of this story. The Oukakai the girls form fits right in with the blossoming of women’s associations during the era, as does the tea party Akiko hosts. I would have liked to see this party in the anime, too. The girls not only show they are nice modern young ladies, they also invite a couple respected intellectuals to the party and are able to use them to thwart Akiko’s father’s attempt to block her from playing baseball.

The cast are still the same smart gals that we’ve learned to love, who won’t take “you can’t do that because you’re a girl” for an answer. And I enjoyed spending more time with them. You need a higher setting on your goggles to see the yuri in the novel. However, we’re still treated to a tasty range of flavors of friendship among the girls.

Ratings:

Art – 7 (though not much, it’s a light novel after all)
Story – 6
Characters – 8
Yuri – 1
Service – 2

Overall – 6

I enjoyed this novel, though it’s not my top for the year. I fear I have been spoiled by the anime, where I feel the adaptation far surpasses the original work. While the novel treats the girls with more dignity than the manga, I feel the anime did better than either. I still recommend this to light novel fans who enjoy strong girls or the Taisho era.

Excellent, George. It sounds like a fun read, and one of those unusual cases of the anime just being better than any of the other media for the series. Both kind of disappointing, but also pretty amazing and cool. Now all we need is an anime company picking up the series for distribution here in the West to make the series a real home run. ^_^



Yawara, A Fashionable Judo Girl Anime, Volumes 5 & 6 (English)

February 9th, 2010

I am vexed.

Very vexed.

Exceedingly vexed.

It’s been a rough day. Technology has been tedious in the extreme. And Yawara, A Fashionable Judo Girl ends in the middle of a total non-arc. I mean, really.

We’ve been talking about it since the beginning. What makes a sports manga work is a rival worthy of our hero/ine. A rival they hate and admire. A rival that pushes them into new heights of achievement. A rival with whom they can be ‘shipped by fans.

Yawara has not one, but four of these. The hapless Sayaka who has everything except satisfaction; Jody Rockwell who was the first one to ever make Yawara really enjoy the art of Judo; the mysterious Belkens of Belgium about which we know little more than her fame; and the masculine, maybe steroided, obviously amoral, Tereshikova of Russia.

So, I’m psyched, we start the final two volumes with the All-Japan Judo Championships. Yawara is distracted, but fighting. We see a glimpse of how clueless she is about Sayaka’s rivalry with her, when she helps Sayaka to beat the annoying Fudou – an act of kindness which is quickly repaid with derision. And then, it all ends, because Sayaka’s injured, so Yawara wins by default.

Which is when the sinking feeling started to hit me.

The next several episodes were clogged with Yawara taking a college exam for a college that will train her to do absolutely nothing useful except husband-hunt, and the trials and tribulations of the people around her who, pathetic as they may be, strive for more.

The best episode by far of the last two volumes was one in which the Judo club formally request a match with Yawara. I was quite teary-eyed at their eagerness to learn from a master of the sport. And I suddenly realized…I didn’t like Yawara at *all.* To have so much skill at a thing, but to want to throw it away at every possible opportunity, feh.

The sinking feeling grew.

Then came one of the worst, most tedious arcs I had ever watched in an anime as Yawara is joined by a fellow first-year in her new school in the hunt for a club to join. I’m surprised I didn’t gouge my eyes out watching this arc, because it was really dumb.

And then…the box set ends.

Seriously, AnimEigo, could you have found a *worse* spot to end the box set? NO ONE will ever want to watch more by the end of Volume 6. If you had ended the box set at the end of Volume 4, we might have sat through 5 and 6 to get to the next arc where she fights but….

Nope.

The sinking feeling of disaster fell into place like a bar of lead.

Yawara is not funny and therefore fails as a comedy, it is not uplifiting and therefore fails as a sports manga; the heroine is a lump and it therefore fails, horribly, as a parody of the above.

I sigh for what was a really wasted opportunity to end this on a great note, so we want more. There were great notes in there, too. But they were buried by the 4 times we had to sit through Grandpa’s retelling of how he met his wife, creepily voiced by Yawara’s VA.

I will remember the good bits, because they are good. But…I am vexed.

Ratings:

Art – 7
Characters – 2, except for Hanazono who is an 8
Story – 1
Yuri – 0
Service – N/A

Overall – Vexing

One last time my sincere thanks to Ana M. for sponsoring today’s review and for doing such a bang-up job on the translation. That, at least, never vexed me once. ^_^

So, my wife asks me at this point – “Would you want the next volume if it came out?” Here’s my response, “Yes, because I’m a hopeless romantic and believe that it has to get better than this. I want to watch Yawara really, truly fight and really, truly win and then I can be done with it.”



Jormungand Manga, Volume 1 (English)

February 8th, 2010

I’m dedicating today’s review to YNN correspondent and sometimes Guest Reviewer here at Okazu, Mara, for turning me on to this series.

Jormungand, Volume 1 is a surprisingly silly look at a grim business – the business of arms dealing. Considered coldly, this may well be one of the most vile occupations possible for a human, since there’s no way to even pretend to be doing anything helpful. Arms dealers profit off of misery and it is in their best interests to keep wars going, (something briefly touched upon in Madlax, as we learn that Friday Monday and his organization are fighting the war strictly to keep the war from ending, so they can make money arming both sides.)

When you think of arms dealers, you might not immediately envision a young, attractive, cracked (but not psychotic,) woman, but that’s what you get in Jormungand – a young woman with the whimsical name Koko Hekmatyar. Because I am the way I am, I looked up her last name and discovered it is an Afghan name. Plausibility is fun.

The story starts with the addition of a taciturn “child-soldier” who hates arms dealers, to Koko’s crack squad of lackeys. I was deeply concerned that the story was going to wallow in Jonah’s tragic past and make us care about him, but thankfully not. Instead, Jonah is whisked into the middle of a crackpot situation in which Koko and her lackeys have *way* more fun than is reasonable killing people. And worse – we have way too much fun watching it. The reason side of my head says, “I really don’t want to be enjoying arms dealer shenanigans” but the comics-reading bit says, “screw that.” It helped when Jonah started to feel that way too.

Koko is crazy in a good way. Not like Balalaika from Black Lagoon, who embodies cool competence. Instead, Koko represents the light comedy style of military leadership, made famous by B.D. of Doonesbury. Only unlike B.D., Koko is more often the joke perpetrator, rather than its brunt.

Yuri in this series is represented by one of Koko’s lackeys, Valmet. Valmet wears an eyepatch, (the medical kind), but is nonetheless hypercomptent with weapons. She states plainly that Koko is the only one she’ll go to the wire for, and is seen many times blushing at the Koko in her head and sometimes even the actual Koko outside her head. She fantasizes about holding Koko in her arms and at least once has the stereotypical nosebleed at Koko’s cuteness. So, yeah, she’s on the team. No one who is sane will expect anything to happen between them, howver. Any fun you’re going to have here will be watching Valmet watching Koko. Valmet herself has a rival/admirer, Mildo, but she’s packed off at the end of the arc. She’ll be back, I have no doubt.

The upshot here is, Jormungand is a fun, action-filled story full of entertainining psychotics, murderers and people who spend their lives helping people kill other people, with a teeny hint of eau de Lys just below the ear.

Ratings:

Art – 7 A little quirky good, and a little quirky bad
Story – 7, It’s not going to be high literature, we just want to see people shoot things
Characters – 8 Koko’s what makes it all work, but once she made Jonah spit-take, I even liked him
Yuri – 2
Service- 11 for military equipment otaku, otherwise, 1

Overall – 8

Thank you Mara, this was the kind of thing I like spending my money on. Even if there is no Yuri in it at all, I’ll be getting the next volume. ^_^