The role of Reviewer will be played tonight by Matt Marcus. He is a cohost of various projects on the Pitch Drop Podcast Network, as well as the author of the blog Oh My God, They Were Bandmates analyzing the manga series How Do We Relationship.
The stage is set: Haruka has resolved to hide her acting past indefinitely while Nao has resolved to break the impasse once she passes her next big audition. Are all the secrets going to spill out? Are we going to finally learn what happened with Haruka in high school? Is Yuki going to ask out her still-in-high-school coworker?
The answers are yes, yes, and thankfully no (for now). Hope you all enjoyed the show! See you next time.
âŠOK thatâs a bit too underwhelming even as a joke, but to be honest the story itself doesnât fare much better.
Woe be me to think that this story centering around The Theatre wouldnât be extra dramatic. A Monologue Woven For You, Volume 3 starts out the gate with Haruka having a minor health scare that motivates Nao to rush to her side, even though her audition is the next day. So whatâs Harukaâs conclusion? Is it that her lover cares very much for her wellbeing? No, itâs that she is going to drag down Nao, snuffing out her shot at thespian greatness. She wrestles with what to do until she discovers the program for her last performance in Naoâs bag, showing that her past was known the whole time. She decides that after seeing Nao off to her audition she will ghost her. You canât become a great artist without a little trauma, right?
You can probably figure out the rest from there. Nao is panicked. She tracks down Jun, who isnât very helpful until she decides to try, at which point she isnât very effective. Haruka meets Rei, the high school theater geek, who unsuccessfully tries to guilt Haruka into un-quitting acting. Somehow, Nao takes a wild leap in logic to deduce that Haruka is sulking in the auditorium in which she last performed. Nao confronts her, prompting Haruka to finally tell her why she quit.
After beginning acting at a young age, Haruka joined a local theater troupe while she was in high school. There she became close friends with a girl a year older who was an accomplished child actor. Haruka looked up to her as her role model. All of that comes crashing down when Haruka beats her out for a leading role. Her friend has a meltdown, blaming Haruka for stealing her golden opportunity, and quits acting altogether. Haruka comes away from this with a deep sense of guilt for âkillingâ the acting career of someone she thought was truly talented. And thatâs it, thatâs the trauma on which this entire plot hinges.
Haruka is still wallowing in this guilt until Nao pushes back, saying that Haruka saved her from quitting acting, and that it is her dream for the two of them to act together on stage. They reconcile, and a year later the two succeed in co-leading a play for their college drama club. Nao goes on to be a professional actor, while Haruka continues to act as a hobby. They move in together, and everyoneâs happy. Cue the orchestra.
I will be honest: I thought the melodrama was both over the top and contrived and the payoff a bit rushed. I donât think after two volumes of teasing that I would ever be satisfied with Harukaâs inciting incident in high school, and what we get is more or less as pedestrian as you could get. I had mentioned in my review of Volume 2 that I wasnât sure if the story wanted me to trust in Harukaâs decision never to act again. Seems a bit foolish now to think that she could have chosen to stay in the audience, but given the way the story framed her stance I think my confusion was warranted. A slightly less storybook ending could have demonstrated Harukaâs outlook maturing as she looks back on the opportunities she threw away. For most people, there are times in your life where you have to give up on participating in something you love but you discover a new way to appreciate it, like an injured athlete becoming a coach. You can wring a lot of impact from such stories of loss, however it would fall flat here because Haruka’s decision to leave the troupe was not foisted upon her; it was entirely self-inflicted. Seriously, someone should have just told her that the fault lies with the girl who quit over a bruised ego. Like, maybe her parents. Or Jun. Or Nao! (I have the âitâs not your faultâ scene from Good Will Hunting running on loop in my head now.) Given where Yasaka-sensei wanted to take the story, it would have been better to seed more hints that Haruka was drawn to act again, but felt ashamed about it.
To pivot away from the story, there is one interesting part of the art that didnât strike me as obvious until this review, which is the use of blur to show depth of field. There are of course cinematic perspective tricks used in other manga, but the way it is implemented here feels somewhat unique. It had been there the whole time–hell, itâs on the Volume 1 cover with the cherry blossoms–but for whatever reason I only noticed it in this volume. Aside from that, there is only one bit of art that I felt was really well composed and drawn, which is the cover page to chapter 15, with Nao standing under a streetlamp at night.
All in all, this series ended up very âmidâ as the kids say. The story could have relied less on contrived and stretched out tension, the art is fine but not amazing, and I donât think it draws out all of the potential out of the college setting. That said, itâs not a bad time. If you want some fluff with a heaping of melodrama, you could do worse.
Art – 7 The art stayed consistent throughout
Story – 6 The melodrama was overwrought
Characters – 5 Theyâre acting to the rafters but they canât elevate the script
Service – 0 Nada
Yuri – 8 / LGBTQ – 1 They teased a second âship but didnât commit
Overall – 7 Would give it a perfunctory standing ovation
